ERIC Identifier: ED342107 Publication Date: 1992-00-00
Author: Weaver, Tyler Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Educational Management Eugene OR.
Year-Round Education. ERIC Digest, Number 68.
Officials in some school districts facing growing student populations and
little or no money for building new facilities are looking at year-round
education (YRE) as a possible solution. By revising the traditional nine-month
calendar, districts can fit more students into a smaller building, thus saving
millions of dollars in new construction costs. Each year the number of schools
adopting YRE grows, and some go so far to say that YRE is the wave of the
Notwithstanding the recent interest, YRE remains a novel concept to most
educators, and objective information regarding year-round calendars is scarce.
Schools usually adopt YRE for its cost-saving features, but a year-round
calendar affects all aspects of a school, from what classes are taught to how
the administration is run. This Digest looks not at the budgetary considerations
of YRE, but at its implications for the educational program.
WHAT DOES A YEAR-ROUND SCHOOL LOOK LIKE?
In most instances,
year-round schools operate on calendars that are
reworkings of a traditional, nine-month calendar. Year-round students attend
the same number of days as their counterparts (180), except that these days are
arranged differently. The most popular YRE calendar is the 45-15 plan, where
students attend school for 45 days and then go on vacation for 15. There are
numerous other types of schedules as well, but the common factor in all YRE
calendars is that students have several short vacations all through the year,
rather than one three-month summer break (Ballinger and others 1987).
A few year-round schools have all their students on the same instructional
and vacation schedule (a singletrack calendar). Most, however, operate on a
multitrack calendar, which groups students onto tracks that have different
instructional and vacation schedules. These tracks are stepped so that there is
always at least one track on vacation (Ballinger and others).
The multitrack calendar allows a school to enroll more students than the
school building was designed to hold. A school in a building built for 750
students can enroll as many as 1,000 students on a four-track calendar (Quinlan
and others 1987). Because of this, the multitrack option is attractive to
schools where population increases are straining existing resources, especially
in urban areas in the western states where the overwhelming majority of
year-round schools are located (Carriedo and Goren 1989).
WHAT ARE THE POSSIBLE EDUCATIONAL BENEFITS OF YRE?
primary educational benefit of YRE is that it facilitates continuous student
learning. According to a study done for the New York Board of Regents (1978),
students forget much of what they learned in school while on a long summer
break. This is particularly true of disadvantaged students and students for whom
English is a second language. With YRE, less is forgotten over the shorter
vacations, and teachers spend less time reviewing (Ballinger and others).
The flexibility of a year-round calendar also offers several benefits. For
example, schools can offer intersession programs where students participate in
advanced, remedial, and enrichment classes (White 1985).
This flexibility can also help migrant students, who are at a serious
disadvantage because they are in and out of school several times each year
(NYBR). Allowing migrant families to choose their children's vacation schedules
may help to keep them in school (Ballinger and others).
Teachers can benefit from YRE's flexibility when schools allow them to work
during the intersessions and earn more money (Ballinger and others). There also
are reports that teachers and students are less likely to burn out and be absent
on a YRE calendar (Quinlan and others).
WHAT IS THE EFFECT ON CURRICULUM?
It goes without saying
that YRE calendars require that educators revamp curriculums. The degree of
change depends on what system a school had before (that is, semesters or
quarters), what kind of calendar is adopted, and whether a school is an
elementary or a high school (White).
At the elementary level, where students are usually with the same teacher all
year, YRE tends to be less disruptive than at the secondary level (White).
However, in multitrack schools, there are always students and teachers who have
to change rooms, as often as four times a year (Carriedo and Goren). Some
schools have to combine students from several grades into one class, which some
teachers consider to be "a dilution to the quality of instruction" (Quinlan and
When YRE is instituted at the secondary level, where teachers are divided
into departments and courses are offered individually, curriculum changes become
more complicated. Secondary schools usually have to revise their graduation
requirements and break up sequenced courses (White).
Multitrack secondary schools experience major curriculum changes. While more
than one track may be in the same term, all the tracks are never in school at
the same time or at the same point in the school year (White). This creates a
problem with advanced, elective, and specialized courses; multitrack schools are
often forced to offer the course several times to small groups or have students
cross-track for special courses (Quinlan and others).
DOES YRE IMPROVE STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT?
Despite the current
interest in YRE, there has been no definitive study done that shows how YRE
affects student achievement. In the words of Carriedo and Goren, while studies
rarely show that YRE lessens achievement, "research findings are mixed and
Merino found that out of nine studies done on achievement in year-round
schools, only three favored YRE, and two of those three studied schools that had
increased the number of instructional days for disadvantaged students. Two
studies indicated that YRE lowered achievement, but overall, research revealed
"no significant differences between the two types of schedules" (Merino 1983).
A study done for the California State Department of Education by Quinlan and
associates sheds further light on the enigmatic relation between YRE and
achievement. Research revealed that California year-round schools have improved
but consistently score below traditional schools, even traditional schools with
similar student populations. Additionally, when singletrack and multitrack
schools were considered separately, the data showed that singletrack schools
perform better than their traditional counterparts, while multitrack schools
Mazzarella (1984), in trying to explain these types of results, points out
that changing calendars and schedules will not improve achievement until
educators learn to use existing schedules more effectively.
WHAT SHOULD SCHOOLS CONSIDER BEFORE ADOPTING YRE?
YRE has the potential to solve budgetary, population, and even academic
problems, YRE affects every part of a school. There are myriad things for
administrators to consider, and some issues, such as how YRE affects families,
are not discussed until there is already a problem. Here is a brief list of some
considerations that might affect a district's decision to implement or not to
*Not all schools are the same. While a year-round school may work in an urban
or migrant environment, that does not mean it will work everywhere. Consider a
school's needs carefully before choosing YRE (White).
*Offseason vacations often cause problems. Student summer activities may be
disrupted. Some year-round schools have worked with the community to ensure that
students will not be left without intersession activities. Offering intersession
classes and activities is also a partial solution to this problem (Oxnard 1990).
*Without the long summer break, teachers may not be able to continue their
own education by taking university classes. Schools may need to offer inservice
*Families and family traditions can be disrupted by YRE, especially if
siblings are attending schools with different calendars. Additionally, many
parents experience difficulty finding offseason childcare (Carriedo and Goren).
*Those who have implemented YRE programs report that community opposition to
year-round programs is usually very strong at the outset. A school or district
should be prepared for opposition (Ballinger and others).
*Although it is poorly documented, year-round administrators are especially
susceptible to burnout. Vacations are harder to schedule, and communication with
teachers and staff can be difficult on a year-round calendar (Goldman 1990).
YRE is a relatively inexpensive method of reform that allows educators to
deal with population increases and budget constraints, reform curriculums, and
renegotiate teacher contracts. However, there are many other aspects of YRE that
lack definitive research, such as its effects on families, students, teachers,
and administrators. It remains to be seen exactly how the recent increase in the
number of year-round schools will affect education as a whole.
Ballinger, Charles E., and others. THE YEAR-ROUND
SCHOOL: WHERE LEARNING NEVER STOPS. Bloomington, Indiana: Phi Delta Kappa
Educational Foundation, 1987. 42 pages. ED 290 210.
Carriedo, Ruben A., and Paul D. Goren. YEAR-ROUND EDUCATION THROUGH
MULTITRACK SCHOOLS. San Francisco: Far West Laboratory for Educational Research
and Development, 1989. 12 pages.
Goldman, Jay P. "Life's a Non-Stop Carousel for Year-Round Principals."
SCHOOL ADMINISTRATOR 74, 4 (April 1990): 25-28. EJ 405 170.
Mazzarella, Jo Ann. "Longer Day, Longer Year: Will They Make a Difference?"
PRINCIPAL 63, 5 (May 1984): 14-20. EJ 305 343.
Merino, Barbara J. "The Impact of Year-Round Schooling: A Review." URBAN
EDUCATION 18, 3 (October 1983): 298-316. EJ 290 857.
New York Board of Regents. LEARNING, RETENTION, AND FORGETTING. Albany, New
York: Author, The Division of Research, 1978. 88 pages. ED 172 324.
Oxnard School District. YEAR-ROUND EDUCATION IN THE OXNARD SCHOOL DISTRICT
AND RELATED YRE REFERENCES. Oxnard, California: Author, 1990. 113 pages. ED 324
Quinlan, Claire, and others. YEAR-ROUND EDUCATION, YEAR-ROUND OPPORTUNITIES: A STUDY OF YEAR-ROUND EDUCATION IN CALIFORNIA. Sacramento: California State Department of Education, 1987. 142 pages. ED 285
White, William D. "Initiating and Administering a Year-Round Program in Your
Secondary School." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Council
on Year-Round Education, Los Angeles, California, January 23-25, 1985. 23 pages.
ED 258 336.