ERIC Identifier: ED373020
Publication Date: 1994-09-00
Author: Hoge, John D.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse for
Social Studies/Social Science Education Bloomington IN.
Achieving History Standards in Elementary Schools. ERIC Digest.
Concern over the quality and quantity of history instruction offered in many
U.S. public schools has resulted in National History Standards for grades K-12.
The National Standards, along with recent research on history learning, have
influenced curriculum guides, textbook revisions, and new instructional
materials in various formats.
RESEARCH ON CHILDREN'S ABILITY TO LEARN HISTORY
can and do understand historical time in a variety of ways (Downey and Levstik
1991). For example, children are capable of reconstructing patterns and
sequences of historical events as they are represented in story-form narratives
(Levstik and Pappas 1987). Children's ability to understand cause and effect
relationships taking place over time--a basic dimension of historical
reasoning--increases throughout childhood and adolescence (Zaccaria 1978). By
the end of 5th grade, students have acquired a good grasp of historical time
terminology, can detect historical anomalies, and show some understanding of
time periods in United States history (Hoge 1991). Research-based conclusions
about the delayed (late adolescence) development of formal historical thinking
ability still stand, though new studies, stimulated by new theories and improved
research methodologies, suggest that this ability arises earlier than indicated
by older studies (Levstik and Pappas 1992).
Different methods of teaching history produce different history learning
outcomes. For example, children taught with a traditional
textbook-worksheet-quiz routine learn more names and dates compared to those
taught in a topically focused, non-survey approach that employs a variety of
instructional materials. However, students in the non-traditional approach
develop better insight into the past, better historical reasoning abilities, and
more positive attitudes toward the subject (Booth 1980).
Downey and Levstik (1991) conclude that history instruction should (1) begin
in the early grades, (2) focus on in-depth, sustained study of significant
material rather than shallow coverage, and (3) make use of age-appropriate
NATIONAL STANDARDS AND THE PURPOSES OF HISTORY INSTRUCTION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
America 2000 set in motion a drive to establish
national standards that would guide history instruction. The three-year effort
of the National History Standards Project resulted in a detailed plan for
teaching historical thinking skills and essential content understandings in
grades K-12. The National Standards project divides thinking skills into five
categories: (1) Chronological Thinking, (2) Historical Comprehension, (3)
Historical Analysis and Interpretation, (4) Historical Research Capabilities,
and (5) Historical Issues-Analysis and Decision-Making.
Content standards are divided into three sets: one for kindergarten through
grade 4, one for United States history, as it is taught at different levels in
grades 5-12, and one for world history, as it is taught at different levels in
grades 5-12. The set of nine content standards for grades K-4 is divided into
the following five topics: (1) Living and Working Together in Families and
Communities, Now and Long Ago, (2) The History of Students' Own State or Region,
(3) The Nation, (4) History of Peoples of Many Cultures Around the World, and
(5) Historic Discoveries in Science & Technology.
Thirty-two content standards in U.S. history for grades 5-12 are distributed
within ten periods or eras: (1) Three Worlds Meet, Beginnings to 1620, (2)
Colonization and Settlement, 1585-1763, (3) Revolution and the New Nation,
1754-1820s, (4) Expansion and Reform, 1801-1861, (5) Civil War and
Reconstruction, 1850-1877, (6) Development of the Industrial United States,
1870-1900, (7) The Emergence of Modern America, 1890-1930, (8) The Great
Depression and World War II, 1929-1945, (9) Postwar United States, 1945-early
1970s, and (10) Contemporary United States, 1968-present.
Thirty-six content standards in world history for grades 5-12 are distributed
within eight eras or periods: (1) The Beginnings of Human Society, (2) Early
Civilizations and the Rise of Pastoral Peoples, 4000-1000 BCE, (3) Classical
Traditions, Major Faiths, and Big Empires, 1000 BCE-300 CE, (4) Expanding Zones
of Exchange and Encounters, 300-1000, (5) Intensified Hemispheric Interactions,
1000-1500, (6) Global Expansion and Encounter, 1450-1770, (7) The Age of
Revolutions, 1750-1914, and (8) The Twentieth Century.
Readers of the National History Standards will have little doubt about what
content they should teach. In addition, the guide illustrates, with numerous
examples, how teachers should address the standards at each of these grade
levels: (1) K-4, (2) 5-8, and (3) 9-12. The standards will doubtlessly be used
to support curriculum development and related testing efforts.
Teaching of history inspired by the National Standards will help elementary
school students achieve important goals of history instruction such as (1)
building knowledge of their heritage and cultures of people around the world;
(2) developing an understanding of continuity, change, and chronology; and (3)
gaining insights into their own lives and contemporary events.
TEACHING PRACTICES THAT DEVELOP HISTORICAL KNOWLEDGE, THINKING SKILLS, AND INTEREST
Children's success in history learning is related to
the quality and quantity of history instruction provided in the school
curriculum. Teachers can meet the National Standards only through systematic
implementation of a well-designed curriculum; one that indicates what to teach
and how to obtain the support needed to fulfill that responsibility. Beyond the
fundamentals of quality curriculum planning and teacher support, there are a
number of classroom teaching practices that can help students develop competence
and interest in the study of history.
Teachers can greatly enhance history instruction by the use of children's
literature. There is a substantial supply of elementary-level historical
fiction, biographies, and special purpose reference works related to history.
Teachers should work with their school media centers and public libraries to
identify the titles of books that may be used to invigorate history learning.
Such books should be displayed attractively, used frequently, and discussed as a
part of the regular classroom routine.
Instruction about the past is aided by the sounds and images of history
offered through laserdiscs, videotapes, films, and filmstrips. Although
overreliance on these resources is a fault, careful selection and meaningful
integration of them with ongoing history instruction can do much to enhance
students' knowledge of the past.
Special experiences pump life into children's history learning. Such
experiences include field trips to museums and historical sites, historical
simulations such as MECC's "Oregon Trail" or Interact's "Discovery 3,"
historical craft and model-building experiences, in-depth National History Day
projects, and the experience of constructing an oral history of some local "big
event." When students are properly prepared for such special history learning
experiences, the depth of understanding gained more than justifies the extra
With younger children it is important to begin teaching about history in the
familiar contexts of their families, classroom, school, and neighborhood. As
students construct familiar histories, ask them to explain--and attempt to
justify--the significance of the events they have selected. Make timelines of
their histories and help students include funny anecdotes and juicy details that
will fuel interest in their stories.
SOURCES OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND IDEAS
experience success in your teaching of history, consider attending a state,
regional, or national social studies conference to share your adventures, gain
new resources, and learn about other teachers' experiences. Join the National
Council for the Social Studies and the National Council for History Education.
Subscribe to HistoryLINK, a free Internet "listserv" supported by the National
Council for History Education, by sending an e-mail subscription request to
or call (216) 835-1776.
Information about the National History Standards Project may be obtained from
The National Center for History in the Schools, University of California, Los
Angeles (UCLA), 10880 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 761, Los Angeles, CA 90024-4108.
It appears that the traditional roles of history
and geography as the leading subjects in elementary social studies will be
further strengthened as a result of the development of the National Standards.
History has much to offer students who are striving to learn about their world
and developing a sense of themselves in it. Skilled teachers can use the
strategies discussed here to help their students learn history and love it!
REFERENCES AND ERIC RESOURCES
The following list includes
references used to prepare this Digest. The items followed by an ED number are
available in microfiche and/or paper copies from the ERIC Document Reproduction
Service (EDRS). For information about prices, contact EDRS, 7420 Fullerton Road,
Suite 110, Springfield, Virginia, 22153-2842; telephone numbers are (703)
440-1400 and (800) 443-3742. Entries followed by an EJ number, announced monthly
in the CURRENT INDEX TO JOURNALS IN EDUCATION (CIJE), are not available through
EDRS. However, they can be located in the journal section of most larger
libraries by using the bibliographic information provided, requested through
Interlibrary Loan, or ordered from the UMI reprint service.
Booth, M. "A Modern World History Course and the Thinking of Adolescent
Pupils." EDUCATIONAL REVIEW 32 (1980): 245-257. EJ 233 556.
Bradley Commission on History in the Schools. BUILDING A HISTORY CURRICULUM:
GUIDELINES FOR TEACHING HISTORY IN SCHOOLS. Washington, DC: Educational
Excellence Network, 1988. ED 310 008.
California Department of Education. LITERATURE FOR HISTORY-SOCIAL SCIENCE,
KINDERGARTEN THROUGH GRADE EIGHT. Sacramento: California Department of
Education, 1991. ED 341 611.
Cleaver, Joanne. DOING CHILDREN'S MUSEUMS: A GUIDE TO 225 HANDS-ON MUSEUMS.
Charlotte, VT: Williamson Publishing, 1988.
Downey, Matthew T., and Linda S. Levstik. "Teaching and Learning History." In
J.P. Shaver, (Ed.) HANDBOOK OF RESEARCH ON SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHING AND LEARNING.
New York: Macmillan Publishing Company, 1992, pp. 400-410.
Hoge, John D. "A Survey Investigation of Students' Historical Time
Knowledge." JOURNAL OF SOCIAL STUDIES RESEARCH 15 (1991): 16-29. EJ 455 120.
Levstik, Linda S., and Christine C. Pappas. "New Directions for Studying
Historical Understanding." THEORY AND RESEARCH IN SOCIAL EDUCATION 20 (1992):
369-385. EJ 464 712.
Levstik, Linda S., and Christine C. Pappas. "Exploring the Development of
Historical Understanding." JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT IN EDUCATION 21
(1987): 1-15. EJ 362 977.
National History Standards Project. PROGRESS REPORT AND DRAFT STANDARDS. Los
Angeles, CA: National Center for History in the Schools, May 1994.
Reed, Elaine W. HELPING YOUR CHILD LEARN HISTORY. Washington, DC: Office of
Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education, 1993. ED 364
Zaccaria, Michael A. "The Development of Historical Thinking: Implications
for the Teaching of History." THE HISTORY TEACHER 11 (1978): 323-340. EJ 180