ERIC Identifier: ED433299
Publication Date: 1999-09-00
Author: Nixon, William A.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse for
Social Studies/Social Science Education Bloomington IN.
The Election of 1800: Teaching about a Critical Moment in the
History of American Constitutional Democracy. ERIC Digest.
As America approaches its 54th presidential election in 2000, we take it for
granted that the candidate who wins that election -- no matter how partisan or
contested it might be -- will become the 43rd President of the United States
following a peaceful transfer of power in a familiar ceremony. Indeed, this
sense of inevitability is clear evidence of the strength of constitutional
democracy in the United States. Aside from the election of 1860, which led to
the Civil War, for two centuries America has met the test that a country is an
established democracy when it consistently makes peaceful changes of government
via free elections (Huntington 1991, 7-9).
But this democratic tradition had to be earned. In 1800 American democracy
faced one of its most serious challenges when Republican Thomas Jefferson defeated Federalist President John Adams. World history reveals that in all too
many cases, political leaders defeated at the ballot have not honored the voice
of the people. But America followed a different course. The Federalists handed
over the reins of power to their hated rivals, setting a precedent that has
guided American politics ever since.
Do students recognize the peaceable outcome of the election of 1800 as one of
the most critical moments in the establishment of constitutional democracy in
America? The approaching bicentennial of Thomas Jefferson's election is an
appropriate time to reflect upon the central place this momentous event should
have in the school curriculum. This Digest connects the election of 1800 to the
social studies curriculum, summarizes core content on this key event in American
history, proposes the use of historic documents by teachers and students, and
recommends World Wide Web sites as sources of documents and related information.
THE ELECTION OF 1800 IN THE SCHOOL CURRICULUM.
The key concept upon which to base treatment of the election of 1800 in the
school curriculum is the crucial role of political parties in the functioning of
American democracy. Though not part of the original constitutional scheme,
parties emerged as an essential means by which Americans peacefully resolve
political disputes. In addition, the election of 1800 should be used to
familiarize students with the electoral system and to expose them to the
important leaders and ideas of the first two political parties. Finally, the
election of 1800 offers an excellent opportunity to teach using historic
The place of the election of 1800 in the school curriculum should grow in
complexity as students advance in maturity and knowledge. Primary and elementary
students should be introduced to the role of political parties, to the process
by which presidents are elected, and to such important leaders of the early
Republic as Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, John Adams, and Alexander Hamilton.
Middle school and high school students can move on to more complex matters, such
as the extra-constitutional nature of political parties, the electoral system
before and after the Twelfth Amendment, the ideology and leadership of the
Federalists and Republicans, and the important issues and events that gave rise
to the first two-party system.
CORE CONTENT ON THE ELECTION OF 1800.
The founding generation earnestly hoped that political parties would not
arise in the United States. Parties were feared as dangerous institutions that
represented a corrupting self-interest. But in the end, two parties, the
Federalists and Republicans, emerged almost in spite of themselves. Though
unanticipated by the Constitution, the United States became the first nation to
establish truly popular parties.
Parties began to form during Washington's first presidential term. The
Federalists coalesced in support of Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton's
economic programs, and the Republicans rallied in opposition under James Madison
and Thomas Jefferson.
Political parties continued to develop in the early 1790s, but as long as
Washington remained in office a true party system could not emerge. While
Washington sided with the Federalists, he was an enormously popular leader who
appeared to be above the dirty business of partisan politics, and no one dared
to challenge him at the ballot.
All that changed when Washington announced his retirement in 1796. The still
primitive national parties now offered competing candidates. Republicans stood
united behind a reluctant Jefferson, while the more factious Federalists offered
two candidates, Vice President John Adams and Thomas Pinckney. In a close
election, Adams carried the vote, but enough Federalist electors refused to vote
for Pinckney that Jefferson received the second highest vote count, making him
the Vice President under the existing terms of the Constitution.
During the presidency of John Adams, parties became more important than ever.
Foreign affairs led to a series of crises that divided Americans, culminating in
the undeclared naval war with France. As war fever gripped the young Republic in
1798, the Federalists, claiming national security, pounced on their domestic
opposition by passing the notorious Alien and Sedition Acts. These measures,
which among other things prohibited criticism of the government by the press,
proved to be one of the great blunders in American political history. The people
had rallied behind the administration against France, but now the Republicans
were able to cast the Federalists as would-be tyrants quashing civil liberties.
Meanwhile, Jefferson and Madison influenced Kentucky and Virginia to pass
resolutions denouncing the Acts and asserting the right of the states to oppose
or nullify unconstitutional laws of the federal government.
As the election of 1800 approached, the nation was in crisis. Jefferson was
again the Republican standard bearer. The Federalists were again divided, with
Hamilton leading an unsuccessful attempt to dump John Adams. The election was
held over the course of May to December 1800, and involved the citizenry only
indirectly. In most states, the legislature chose the electors, and much
behind-the-scenes wrangling took place.
The Republicans emerged victorious, but then the unexpected happened. Under
the Constitution at that time, each elector was to vote for two candidates
without specifying who was to be president or vice president. By mistake
Jefferson received the same number of votes as his running mate Aaron Burr,
deadlocking the electoral college. The election went to the House of
Representatives, where each state had one vote. Burr refused to step aside, and
the election was deadlocked for almost a week. By the 36th ballot Jefferson was
elected. In 1804 the Twelfth Amendment corrected this problem by requiring
electors to vote separately for president and vice president.
Thomas Jefferson became the third president in a peaceful transfer of power.
In his inaugural address of March 4, 1801, he made a gesture of conciliation to
his defeated rivals that set the tone for future party politics in America. The
campaign had been bitter, he noted, but now the country must unite. Though the
parties disagreed about much, what they shared was more important.
TEACHING WITH HISTORIC DOCUMENTS.
The election of 1800
provides an outstanding opportunity for teachers who want to use historic
documents in the classroom as an exciting way to more directly engage students
with the past while fostering analytical and interpretive skills. Jefferson's
First Inaugural Address is one of the most significant speeches in American
history, and offers a unique window into the complex political views of this
leading member of the founding generation. Moreover, Jefferson's language in his
First Inaugural Address is closer to contemporary usage than that of many other
important texts from this era, and because of that the address serves as a good
text for introducing students to the political discourse of the early Republic.
The full text of the address is available through the Web resources listed
WORLD WIDE WEB RESOURCES FOR TEACHING ABOUT THE ELECTION OF 1800.
The following World Wide Web sites are recommended to teachers and students
of United States history.
* Inaugural Lesson Plan: Thomas Jefferson -- the Revolution of 1800.
Maintained by PBS Online and created in association with the Presidential
Inaugural Committee for 1997, this site is ideal for Web-based teaching of the
election of 1800. Content, however, may be too sophisticated for younger
students. The site includes historical background, activities, a link to the
full text of Jefferson's inaugural speech, and clear guidelines for using this
* Thomas Jefferson, John Adams and the Election of 1800. This educational
site, created by Dr. Patrick Novotny of Georgia Southern University, provides a
solid overview of the election of 1800. It also includes contemporary political
cartoons, an electoral map, and a link to a site on the Alien and Sedition Acts.
* Monticello, The Home of Thomas Jefferson. The award-winning official site
of Monticello includes "A Day in the Life," "Matters of Fact," lesson plans, and
the highly recommended "Ask Thomas Jefferson," designed for K-12 students.
* White House Homepage: John Adams and Thomas Jefferson. This site offers
concise biographies of John Adams and Thomas Jefferson. Like the other
presidential Web biographies assembled by the White House, these provide
information on the First Ladies, links to inaugural speeches, and quotations.
* Thomas Jefferson Papers at the Library of Congress. This site is part of
the Library of Congress's outstanding American Memory project. At present,
digitized versions of several thousand of Jefferson's papers and letters are
available here. Eventually, the complete Jefferson papers will be digitized and
accessible at this site. (http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/mtjhtml/mtjhome.html)
References and ERIC Resources.
The following list of resources includes references used to prepare this
Digest. The items followed by an ED number are available in microfiche and/or
paper copies from the ERIC Document Reproduction Service (EDRS). For information
about prices, contact EDRS, 7420 Fullerton Road, Suite 110, Springfield,
Virginia 22153-2852; telephone numbers are (703) 440-1400 and (800) 443-3742.
Entries followed by an EJ number, annotated monthly in CURRENT INDEX TO JOURNALS
IN EDUCATION (CIJE), are not available through EDRS. However, they can be
located in the journal section of most larger libraries by using the
bibliographic information provided, requested through Interlibrary Loan, or
ordered from commercial reprint services.
Holbrook-DeFeo, Gary. "The Election of 1800: Alexander Hamilton and the Death
of the Federalist Party." NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF HISTORY 49 (Winter 1993):
26-40. EJ 467 858.
Hunter, Kathleen. TEACHING USING HISTORIC PLACES: THOMAS JEFFERSON'S ROAD TO
THE WHITE HOUSE. Washington, DC: National Park Service, 1993. ED 365 599.
Huntington, Samuel P. THE THIRD WAVE: DEMOCRATIZATION IN THE LATE TWENTIETH
CENTURY. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.
Peterson, Merrill D. "Thomas Jefferson: The Architect of Democracy." SOCIAL
EDUCATION 58 (October 1994): 359-362. EJ 496 918.
Sharp, James Roger. AMERICAN POLITICS IN THE EARLY REPUBLIC: THE NEW NATION
IN CRISIS. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993.