Differentiation of Instruction in the Elementary
Grades. ERIC Digest.
by Tomlinson, Carol Ann
In most elementary classrooms, some students struggle with learning,
others perform well beyond grade-level expectations, and the rest fit somewhere
in between. Within each of these categories of students, individuals also
learn in a variety of ways and have different interests. To meet the needs
of a diverse student population, many teachers differentiate instruction.
This Digest describes differentiated instruction, discusses the reasons
for differentiating instruction, discusses what makes it successful, and
suggests how teachers can start implementing it.
WHAT IS DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION?
At its most basic level, differentiation consists of the efforts of
teachers to respond to variance among learners in the classroom. Whenever
a teacher reaches out to an individual or small group to vary his or her
teaching in order to create the best learning experience possible, that
teacher is differentiating instruction.
Teachers can differentiate at least four classroom elements based on
student readiness, interest, or learning profile: (1) content--what the
student needs to learn or how the student will get access to the information;
(2) process--activities in which the student engages in order to make sense
of or master the content; (3) products--culminating projects that ask the
student to rehearse, apply, and extend what he or she has learned in a
unit; and (4) learning environment--the way the classroom works and feels.
Content. Examples of differentiating content at the elementary level
include the following: (1) using reading materials at varying readability
levels; (2) putting text materials on tape; (3) using spelling or vocabulary
lists at readiness levels of students; (4) presenting ideas through both
auditory and visual means; (5) using reading buddies; and (6) meeting with
small groups to re-teach an idea or skill for struggling learners, or to
extend the thinking or skills of advanced learners.
Process. Examples of differentiating process or activities at the elementary
level include the following: (1) using tiered activities through which
all learners work with the same important understandings and skills, but
proceed with different levels of support, challenge, or complexity; (2)
providing interest centers that encourage students to explore subsets of
the class topic of particular interest to them; (3) developing personal
agendas (task lists written by the teacher and containing both in-common
work for the whole class and work that addresses individual needs of learners)
to be completed either during specified agenda time or as students complete
other work early; (4) offering manipulative's or other hands-on supports
for students who need them; and (5) varying the length of time a student
may take to complete a task in order to provide additional support for
a struggling learner or to encourage an advanced learner to pursue a topic
in greater depth.
Products. Examples of differentiating products at the elementary level
include the following: (1) giving students options of how to express required
learning (e.g., create a puppet show, write a letter, or develop a mural
with labels); (2) using rubrics that match and extend students' varied
skills levels; (3) allowing students to work alone or in small groups on
their products; and (4) encouraging students to create their own product
assignments as long as the assignments contain required elements.
Learning Environment. Examples of differentiating learning environment
at the elementary level include: (1) making sure there are places in the
room to work quietly and without distraction, as well as places that invite
student collaboration; (2) providing materials that reflect a variety of
cultures and home settings; (3) setting out clear guidelines for independent
work that matches individual needs; (4) developing routines that allow
students to get help when teachers are busy with other students and cannot
help them immediately; and (5) helping students understand that some learners
need to move around to learn, while others do better sitting quietly (Tomlinson,
1995, 1999; Winebrenner, 1992, 1996).
WHY DIFFERENTIATE INSTRUCTION IN THE ELEMENTARY GRADES?
A simple answer is that students in the elementary grades vary greatly,
and if teachers want to maximize their students' individual potential,
they will have to attend to the differences.
There is ample evidence that students are more successful in school
and find it more satisfying if they are taught in ways that are responsive
to their readiness levels (e.g., Vygotsky, 1986), interests (e.g., Csikszentmihalyi,
1997) and learning profiles (e.g., Sternberg, Torff, & Grigorenko,
1998). Another reason for differentiating instruction relates to teacher
professionalism. Expert teachers are attentive to students' varied learning
needs (Danielson, 1996); to differentiate instruction, then, is to become
a more competent, creative, and professional educator.
WHAT MAKES DIFFERENTIATION SUCCESSFUL?
The most important factor in differentiation that helps students achieve
more and feel more engaged in school is being sure that what teachers differentiate
is high-quality curriculum and instruction. For example, teachers can make
sure that: (1) curriculum is clearly focused on the information and understandings
that are most valued by an expert in a particular discipline; (2) lessons,
activities, and products are designed to ensure that students grapple with,
use, and come to understand those essentials; (3) materials and tasks are
interesting to students and seem relevant to them; (4) learning is active;
and (5) there is joy and satisfaction in learning for each student.
One challenge for teachers leading a differentiated classroom is the
need to reflect constantly on the quality of what is being differentiated.
Developing three avenues to an ill-defined outcome is of little use. Offering
four ways to express trivia is a waste of planning time and is unlikely
to produce impressive results for learners.
There is no recipe for differentiation. Rather, it is a way of thinking
about teaching and learning that values the individual and can be translated
into classroom practice in many ways. Still, the following broad principles
and characteristics are useful in establishing a defensible differentiated
* ASSESSMENT IS ONGOING AND TIGHTLY LINKED TO INSTRUCTION. Teachers
are hunters and gatherers of information about their students and how those
students are learning at a given point. Whatever the teachers can glean
about student readiness, interest, and learning helps the teachers plan
next steps in instruction.
* TEACHERS WORK HARD TO ENSURE "RESPECTFUL ACTIVITIES" FOR ALL STUDENTS.
Each student's work should be equally interesting, equally appealing, and
equally focused on essential understandings and skills. There should not
be a group of students that frequently does "dull drill" and another that
generally does "fluff." Rather, everyone is continually working with tasks
that students and teachers perceive to be worthwhile and valuable.
* FLEXIBLE GROUPING IS A HALLMARK OF THE CLASS. Teachers plan extended
periods of instruction so that all students work with a variety of peers
over a period of days. Sometimes students work with like-readiness peers,
sometimes with mixed-readiness groups, sometimes with students who have
similar interests, sometimes with students who have different interests,
sometimes with peers who learn as they do, sometimes randomly, and often
with the class as a whole. In addition, teachers can assign students to
work groups, and sometimes students will select their own work groups.
Flexible grouping allows students to see themselves in a variety of contexts
and aids the teacher in "auditioning" students in different settings and
with different kinds of work (Tomlinson, 1995, 1999).
WHAT IS THE BEST WAY TO BEGIN DIFFERENTIATION?
Teachers are as different as their learners. Some teachers naturally
and robustly differentiated instruction early in their careers. For other
teachers, establishing a truly flexible and responsive classroom seems
daunting. It is helpful for a teacher who wants to become more effective
at differentiation to remember to balance his or her own needs with those
of the students. Once again, there are no recipes. Nonetheless, the following
guidelines are helpful to many teachers as they begin to differentiate,
begin to differentiate more proactively, or seek to refine a classroom
that can already be called "differentiated":
* Frequently reflect on the match between your classroom and the philosophy
of teaching and learning you want to practice. Look for matches and mismatches,
and use both to guide you.
* Create a mental image of what you want your classroom to look like,
and use it to help plan and assess changes.
* Prepare students and parents for a differentiated classroom so that
they are your partners in making it a good fit for everyone. Be sure to
talk often with students about the classroom--why it is the way it is,
how it is working, and what everyone can do to help.
* Begin to change at a pace that pushes you a little bit beyond your
comfort zone--neither totally duplicating past practice nor trying to change
everything overnight. You might begin with just one subject, just one time
of the day, or just one curricular element (content, process, product,
or learning environment).
* Think carefully about management routines--for example, giving directions,
making sure students know how to move about the room, and making sure students
know where to put work when they finish it.
* Teach the routines to students carefully, monitor the effectiveness
of the routines, discuss results with students, and fine tune together.
* Take time off from change to regain your energy and to assess how
things are going.
* Build a support system of other educators. Let administrators know
how they can support you. Ask specialists (e.g., in gifted education, special
education, second language instruction) to co-teach with you from time
to time so you have a second pair of hands and eyes. Form study groups
on differentiation with like-minded peers. Plan and share differentiated
materials with colleagues.
* Enjoy your own growth. One of the great joys of teaching is recognizing
that the teacher always has more to learn than the students and that learning
is no less empowering for adults than for students.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1997). FINDING FLOW: THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ENGAGEMENT
WITH EVERYDAY LIFE. New York: Basic Books.
Danielson, C. (1996). ENHANCING PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE: A FRAMEWORK FOR
TEACHING. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
ED 403 245.
Sternberg, R. J., Torff, B., & Grigorenko, E. L. (1998). Teaching
triarchically improves student achievement. JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY,
90(3), 374-384. EJ 576 492.
Tomlinson, C. (1995). HOW TO DIFFERENTIATE INSTRUCTION IN MIXED-ABILITY
CLASSROOMS. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
Development. ED 386 301.
Tomlinson, C. (1999). THE DIFFERENTIATED CLASSROOM: RESPONDING TO THE
NEEDS OF ALL LEARNERS. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and
Curriculum Development. ED 429 944.
Vygotsky, L. (1986). THOUGHT AND LANGUAGE. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Winebrenner, S. (1992). TEACHING GIFTED KIDS IN THE REGULAR CLASSROOM.
Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit. Winebrenner, S. (1996). TEACHING KIDS WITH
LEARNING DIFFICULTIES IN THE REGULAR CLASSROOM. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit.
ED 396 502.