ERIC Identifier: ED448248
Publication Date: 2000-12-00
Author: Schwartz, Wendy
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban Education New York NY.
Preventing Student Sexual Harassment. ERIC Digest Number 160.
Peer sexual harassment among students is a complex, and widespread, problem with significant effects on the perpetrator, the victim, and the school environment. While most targets do not report harassment, surveys indicate that well over half of all students have been harassed, with females, youth of color, and gays most frequently targeted (American Association of University Women, AAUW, 1993; Gustavsson, & MacEachron, 1998; Shoop & Hayhow, 1994). Schools, under both social and legal pressure, are developing policies for keeping their environment safe for all students and procedures for dealing appropriately with harassment when it occurs. This digest reviews effective anti-harassment strategies currently employed by schools.
PEER SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Sexual harassment is considered any "unwelcome behavior of a sexual nature that interferes with" the life of the target(s); it is "unsolicited and nonreciprocal" (Shoop & Edwards, 1994, p. 17). Harassment includes use of sexist terms, comments about body parts, sexual advances, unwanted touching, gestures, taunting, sexual graffiti, and rumor mongering about a classmate's sexual identity or activity. Generally, any behavior of a sexual nature that provokes undesirable, uncomfortable feelings in a target can be considered harassment. Repeated harassment is bullying (Sexual Harassment Guidance, 1997; Stein & Sjostrom, 1994).
Experts agree that sexual harassment is about power, not sex. The deeply ingrained societal beliefs that women should be subservient to men, and that "real men" are macho, foster boys' convictions that harassment is an acceptable way to communicate with girls. The advertising and entertainment media perpetuate these prejudices and stereotypes, and family behaviors may do so as well (Shoop & Edwards, 1994). Further, the current practice of integrating girls into classes and activities previously dominated by boys can threaten boys' self-concept of superiority, and cause them to act out alone or in groups (Shoop & Edwards, 1994).
The lives of girls targeted for harassment are often severely compromised. Targets may become truant and less academically successful. They may feel self-conscious, and even develop psychopathologies and physical symptoms (AAUW, 1993; Shoop & Hayhow, 1994).
Legally, sexual harassment is considered a form of sex discrimination, and is specifically prohibited by several Federal laws and an array of state laws. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 has been extended by some courts to include peer harassment in school. Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 has been used to financially compensate victims of harassment in schools. Another Federal civil rights law, 42 U.S.C. 1983, has also been used successfully to sue schools that failed to protect students from peer harassment (Sexual Harassment Guidance, 1997).
SCHOOL INITIATIVES ON SEXUAL HARASSMENT
A serious effort keep a school free of sexual harassment involves the commitment of the whole school (and district) community and requires a systemic, multidimensional approach and long-term educational strategies. The goals are to maintain an environment that fosters appropriate and respectful behavior and cooperative interactions among students; to employ only non-sexist curriculum and teaching methods; to promote staff modeling of non-sexist behavior; and to indicate clearly that harassment will not be tolerated (Brandenburg, 1997; Protecting Students, 1999; Shoop & Edwards, 1994).
Student Education about Harassmenet
All education about harassment needs to be age and grade appropriate. It should describe what types of conduct constitute harassment; but, to reduce the possibility of establishing a climate of fear, the curriculum should help students distinguish between contact perceived as menacing (and a violation of the target's privacy) and flirting, which can be desired, feels good, makes the recipient happy, and increases self-esteem (Shoop & Hayhow, 1994; Steineger, 1997).
A curriculum on human sexuality can easily cover harassment, but the problem can also be discussed in other courses: history, social studies, contemporary issues, English, and health education. Co-teaching by males and females sends "a powerful message...about the relevance of sexual harassment to both sexes" (Stein & Sjostrom, 1994, p. 3). Classes should include both male and female students so they can gain an understanding of each other's perceptions. It is critical not to make the males feel threatened (Brandenburg, 1997).
Because empowerment is one of the best ways to prevent harassment, schools need to build students' self-esteem. Girls can be taught "assertiveness skills" to enable them to express their feelings clearly and help them stop harassment should it occur. Boys can be taught how to communicate with girls in positive ways. Discussions of sex roles and gender stereotypes can provide valuable information about both sexes. Guest speakers, videos, printed materials, and web sites can enliven discussions. Finally, curricula should help students understand that engaging in harassment is a choice that someone makes (Brandenburg, 1997; Protecting Students, 1999; Shoop & Edwards, 1994).
Every school (and district) should have a policy that prohibits all forms of sexual harassment and mandates equitable treatment for all students. It should be comprehensive, clearly written, and sufficiently explicit so that students and parents, as well as educators, know what is expected of everyone. It should also be reevaluated and reissued annually.
The policy should urge the targets of sexual harassment to report their victimization promptly. It should announce that all complaints will be full heeded, and that retaliation against complainants will be not tolerated. The policy should state that unbiased investigators, who are named, will conduct a full hearing. It should also indicate that complainants' statements will be kept as confidential as is possible, that complainants do not have to face their harassers, and that complainants can end the school's informal practice at any time and make a formal criminal complaint. It should also state that the goal of the investigation will be a fair resolution that includes, if warranted, appropriate and corrective action. Possible consequences for harassment should be specified (Shoop & Hayhow, 1994; Steineger, 1997).
A school's anti-harassment policy must be well-publicized throughout the school and community, through public posting and age-appropriate discussion. It should also be provided to families (Protecting Students, 1999; Shoop & Edwards, 1994).
Responses to Harassment
Attempts to elicit information should give everyone involved (including witnesses) the opportunity to describe the harassment and convey relevant information in their own words. The targets should be asked about the effects of the harassment on them personally and the solution to the problem that they desire, such as cessation of the offensive behavior, an apology, a transfer out of the class or activity where the harassment occurred, counseling for the harasser, school punishment of the harasser, or the filing of criminal charges. They should be given support, including counseling if warranted (Shoop & Edwards, 1994; Shoop & Hayhow, 1994).
The consequences for harassers should include re-mediation as well as punishment; they need to appreciate that their actions are harmful and to learn more acceptable behavior (Protecting Students, 1999). Punishment should fit the offense in severity, both because that is fair and because under- or over-reactions diminish respect for the problem of harassment (Stein, 1999).
Schools can also choose to use the "student empowerment approach," whereby targets confront their harassers. This strategy, which prevents accused harassers from claiming their behavior was welcomed, can be effective; one-third stop their offensive behavior when directly confronted (Shoop & Edwards, 1994). Meetings should occur only in the presence of the school investigator. Alternatively, targets can write their harassers a letter, fully stating what they believe happened, how they feel about it, and what they want to happen next. Targets should never be coerced into attending a meeting or writing a letter; and the accused should not be forced into a meeting (Protecting Students, 1999; Stein, 1999).
Schools should schedule a half to a full day of interactive training on sexual harassment and violence, facilitated by an expert in the field, for all staff members. Training should cover the nature of harassment, ways to spot it and changes in students which suggest they are being targeted, procedures for reporting harassment, and strategies for dealing with the claimants and the accused. Staff designated as investigators and teachers whose curricula contain information about harassment should receive additional training (Protecting Students, 1999; Shoop & Edwards, 1994; Stein, 1999; Steineger, 1997).
Children learn how to view, and respond to, the world from a variety of sources, especially their families, who provide a de facto education through their own conduct. Parents can also help their children make judgments about what they see and hear in the media and community, build self-esteem that deflects negative emotions resulting from victimization, and develop skills to resist personal impulses and peer pressure to behave badly. They can respond to the targeting of their children by believing what they say and helping them report incidents (Shoop & Hayhow, 1994).
Schools can educate parents about sexual harassment through meetings and workshops that explain their anti-harassment policy and enlist their support and suggestions. They can also describe gender-fair child-rearing strategies and offer suggestions for parent-child discussions on related issues: sex education, sex equity, and sexism (Brandenburg, 1997; Stein, 1999).
Parents who believe that their children's school does not have a comprehensive policy, or that its staff does not understand the relationship between sexual stereotyping, sexism, and sexual harassment, have an obligation to seek a response to their concerns.
While the overall climate of tolerance has been increasing in the U.S., hostility--and even exhortations to violence--toward groups prone to verbal and physical victimization expressed in some popular music and films have become more pronounced. Youth are most susceptible to these messages, and unchecked verbal and physical sexual harassment in children can lead to even more destructive behavior when they become adults, such as domestic violence and hate crime (Shoop & Hayhow, 1994). Thus, the need for schools and families to deliver a strong and effective anti-harassment message has become even more necessary.
American Association of University Women. (1993). Hostile hallways: The AAUW survey on sexual harassment in America's schools. Washington, DC: Author. (ED 356 186)
Brandenburg, J.B. (1997). Confronting sexual harassment: What schools and colleges can do. New York: Teachers College Press. Gustavsson, N.S., & MacEachron, A.E. (1998).Violence and lesbian and gay youth. Journal of Gay & Lesbian Social Services, 8(3), 41-50. (EJ 574 642)
Protecting students from harassment and hate crime: A guide for schools (Revised). (1999, September). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights. (ED 431 246)
Sexual harassment guidance: Harassment of students by school employees, other students, or third parties. (1997, March). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights. (ED 405 645)
Shoop, R.J., & Edwards, D.L. (1994). How to stop sexual harassment in our schools: A handbook and curriculum guide for administrators and teachers. Boston: Allyn and Bacon. (ED 386 794)
Shoop, R.J., & Hayhow, J.W., Jr. (1994). Sexual harassment in our schools: What parents and teachers need to know to spot it and stop it. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Stein, N. (1999). Classrooms & courtrooms: Facing sexual harassment in K-12 schools. New York: Teachers College Press. (ED 438 617)
Stein, N., & Sjostrom, L. (1994). Flirting or hurting? A teacher's guide to student-to-student sexual harassment in schools (Grades 6 through 12). Washington, DC: National Education Association. (ED 380 415)
Steineger, M. (1997). Preventing and countering school-based harassment: A resource guide for K-12 educators. Portland, OR: Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory. (ED 420 113)
Please note that this site is privately owned and is in no way related to any Federal agency or ERIC unit. Further, this site is using a privately owned and located server. This is NOT a government sponsored or government sanctioned site. ERIC is a Service Mark of the U.S. Government. This site exists to provide the text of the public domain ERIC Documents previously produced by ERIC. No new content will ever appear here that would in any way challenge the ERIC Service Mark of the U.S. Government.