ERIC Identifier: ED464525
Publication Date: 2001-12-00
Author: Loane, Shannon
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Higher Education Washington DC.
Distance Education and Accreditation. ERIC Digest.
In 1997-1998, there were more than 1.3 million enrollments in college-level, credit-granting distance education courses - approximately double the almost 754,000 formal enrollments in 1994-1995 (Lewis, Snow, Farris, and Levin, 1999, p. 50). The number of courses offered also almost doubled, with the nearly 26,000 distance education courses offered by 2- and 4-year higher education institutions in 1994-1995 growing to more than 47,500 different college-level courses in 1997-1998 (Lewis, Snow, Farris, and Levin, 1999, p. 49).
This rapid growth in distance education has created the potential for fraud and abuse. With so many courses and programs offered by so many providers, how can students determine which courses and programs are worthwhile - and which ones are shams? This digest will, after reviewing some information on distance education, discuss accreditation, the traditional method of determining the quality of higher education offerings in the United States, and its application to distance education.
The current explosion in distance education is attributable to the development and spread of new technologies. In 1997-1998, the most popular technology for offering distance education courses was Internet courses using asynchronous computer-based instruction. Sixty percent of higher education institutions offering distance education courses used this technology, up from 22 percent in 1995. Other popular technologies included two-way interactive video (56 percent), one-way prerecorded video (48 percent), Internet courses using synchronous computer-based instruction (19 percent), and one-way video with two-way audio (14 percent) (Lewis, Snow, Farris, and Levin, 1999, p. 52).
There are other variables in distance education. Students can do anything from taking a single course, which may or may not require occasional meetings on campus, to completing an entire degree or program online. Distance education courses or programs may be offered by traditional bricks-and-mortar universities or colleges, by "virtual" institutions whose entire offerings are online, by online consortia, or by for-profit institutions.
Its supporters claim that distance education is more convenient and accessible for nontraditional students - an increasingly large percentage of the higher education population (American Association of University Professors, May-June 1998, p. 31; Trinkle, 1999, August 6). Distance education allows these students to pursue an education in addition to fulfilling their commitments to jobs and families. It also provides accessibility for those not located near a traditional college or university. Supporters also point to cost savings - with virtual courses, educational institutions can accommodate greater numbers of students without incurring the costs of new buildings and classrooms (Dasher-Alton, Patton, 1998, p. 13).
Critics of distance education, however, question whether there are genuine cost savings, after taking into account the investment in infrastructure, the work involved in adapting or creating a course for delivery through computer-based instruction, and the need to provide distance education students with basic university functions, such as registration, advising, and access to library materials (American Association of University Professors, May-June 1998, pp. 32-33).
They also question the quality of the online educational experience, and point to the increasing publicity about online "diploma mills" as an example of what happens when students cannot see what they are paying for. "Diploma mills" are fraudulent institutions that offer worthless degrees, many requiring little or no coursework, in exchange for money. Such institutions have existed in the past, but the Internet offers them the ability not only to reach many more potential students, but also to attract these students through enticing and misleading websites.
The Department of Education lists the following as some of the functions of accreditation:
1. Verifying that an institution or program meets established standards;
2. Assisting prospective students in identifying acceptable institutions;
3. Assisting institutions in determining the acceptability of transfer credits;
4. Helping to identify institutions and programs for the investment of public and private funds;
5. Protecting an institution against harmful internal and external pressure;
6. Creating goals for self-improvement of weaker programs and stimulating a general raising of standards among educational institutions;
7. Involving the faculty and staff comprehensively in institutional evaluation and planning;
8. Establishing criteria for professional certification and licensure and for upgrading courses offering such preparation; and
9. Providing one of several considerations used as a basis for determining eligibility for Federal assistance.
(U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. Accreditation in the U.S.)
The nationally recognized accrediting agencies offer three basic types of accreditation: regional, national, and specialized.
Regional: The six regional accrediting agencies evaluate entire institutions, not the individual programs within them. An institution with regional accreditation has satisfied the agency that it meets the accreditation standards as a whole, and that each of its programs, while not necessarily all of the same quality, contributes to the institution's standing. All state universities, most private colleges, and most private research institutions, are regionally accredited (Lezberg, Summer 1999) diverse programs. Examples of the types of institutions that might have national accreditation are Bible colleges and other theological schools or distance education.
National: National accreditation also focuses on the entire Institution, but usually on institutions with a very narrow focus, not universities or colleges with many institutions.
Specialized: Specialized accreditors evaluate individual programs, usually within an institution (that institution probably holds regional or national accreditation as a whole). These programs are often those leading to a professional degree. Programs in law, medicine, and business are among those that have specialized accreditation.
THE CHALLENGES DISTANCE EDUCATION POSES FOR ACCREDITATION
* Many of the measures used in traditional accreditation reviews do not apply to online institutions - among these are the institution's full-time faculty, the number of volumes in the research library, and the amount of time that students are in class (Wellman, 2000, September 22).
* How can it be determined if a course offered online is equivalent to a traditional classroom based course?
* Who will accredit a university that does not have a physical campus? Regional accreditation, as its name suggests, is based on the physical location of the institution. Western Governors University, a collaboration of 18 states and Guam, has its administrative headquarters in Utah (located within the Northwest Association of Schools and Colleges accreditation region) and its academic headquarters in Colorado (located within the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools accreditation region).
* Even for those institutions that do have a physical campus, what happens when the student is in another region and never sets foot on the physical campus?
Educators are divided on these and other questions. Some educators believe that current accreditation standards, with some changes, are flexible enough to accommodate distance education programs (Olsen, 1999, August 6). Others believe that distance education means major changes, and possibly a challenge to the very idea of accreditation (Wellman, 2000, September 22; Carnevale, 2000, February 18).
CURRENT STATUS OF DISTANCE EDUCATION AND ACCREDITATION
The Department of Education has determined that distance education "is considered to be implicitly included in the scope of recognition of any accrediting agency that was recognized by the Secretary on or before October 1, 1998, provided the agency was engaged in accrediting review activities related to distance education at that time. Since December 1999, the Department has been routinely including distance education in its in-depth review of all agencies seeking initial or continued recognition. Consequently, all recognition decisions made after December 1, 1999 include a determination as to whether or not an agency's scope of recognition includes the accreditation of distance education" (U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. Nationally Recognized Accreditation Agencies).
In addition, the Department of Education has granted the Accrediting Commission of the Distance Education and Training Council (DETC) the authority to accredit "private and non-private distance education institutions offering non-degree and associate, baccalaureate, and master's degree programs primarily through the distance learning method" (U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. National Institutional and Specialized Accrediting Bodies - Distance Education and Training Council).
The regional accrediting agencies joined together in the Council of Regional Accrediting Commissions to work for consistency across regions in distance education accreditation. Two documents developed by the Council, Statement of Commitment by the Regional Accrediting Commissions for the Evaluation of Electronically Offered Degree and Certificate Programs and Best Practices for Electronically Offered Degree and Certificate Programs, are under consideration by the individual agencies (Carnevale, 2000, September 8; Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, Western Cooperative for Educational Telecommunications. Regional Accrediting Agency Documents on Electronically Offered Degree and Certificate Programs).
The North Central Association of Colleges and Schools has been one of the more active regional accrediting agencies in the area of distance education institutions. In 1999, it accredited Jones International University, the first completely virtual university to win accreditation status from a regional accrediting agency (Olsen, 1999, August 6). North Central has also granted DeVry Institutes accreditation for its online bachelor's degree programs (Blumenstyk, 2000, September 8). And, along with three other regional accrediting agencies, North Central has formed the Inter-Regional Accrediting Committee (IRAC) to create and implement an accreditation plan for Western Governors University (WGU) (Guernsey, 1997, December 19). WGU, which has already been accredited by DETC, received "Candidate for Accreditation" status from IRAC in November 2000 (Western Governors University. About WGU).
HOW TO DETERMINE IF A DISTANCE EDUCATION PROGRAM IS ACCREDITED
Confirm any information received about an institution's accreditation with the Department of Education and the accrediting agency in question. Department of Education-recognized accrediting agencies are listed on the Department of Education website at http://www.ed.gov/offices/OPE/accreditation/natlagencies.html. From this site, one may link to the accrediting agency's website and determine whether a particular institution is on its list of accredited institutions.
Blumenstyk, G. (2000, September 8). DeVry receives accreditation to offer bachelor's degrees online [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A61.
Carnevale, D. (2000, February 18). Assessing the quality of online courses remains a challenge, educators agree [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A59.
Carnevale, D. (2000, September 8). Accrediting bodies consider new standards for distance-education programs [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A58.
Dasher-Alton, R. and Patton, G. (1998). Evaluation criteria for distance learning. Planning for Higher Education 27(1): 11-17. EJ 573 791
Eaton, J. (2001) Distance learning: Academic and political challenges for higher education accreditation. (Council for Higher Education Accreditation, CHEA Monograph Series 2001, Number 1). Retrieved October 5, 2001 from the Council for Higher Education Accreditation web site: http://www.chea.org/Research/distance-learning/chea_dis_learning.pdf
Guernsey, L. (1997, December 19). Is the Internet becoming a bonanza for diploma mills? [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A22. EJ 558 370
Lewis, L., Snow, K., Farris, E., Levin, D. (1999). Distance education at postsecondary education institutions: 1997-98. (National Center for Education Statistics Report No. 2000-13). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
Lezberg, A. (Summer 1999). Regional accreditation and distance education. The Advising Quarterly. Retrieved July 20, 2001 from: http://www.amideast.org/publications/aq/Back_Issues/1999/Su99-html/ Su99Regional.htm
Olsen, F. (1999, August 6). 'Virtual' institutions challenge accreditors to devise new ways of measuring quality [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A29. EJ 591 478
Spille, H., Stewart, D., Sullivan, E. (1997). External Degrees in the Information Age. Legitimate Choices. Phoenix, AZ: Oryx Press.
Trinkle, D. (1999, August 6). Point of view: Distance education: A means to an end, no more, no less [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. A60.
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. Accreditation in the U.S. Retrieved November 14, 2001 from the Department of Education web site: http://www.ed.gov/offices/OPE/accreditation/accredus.html
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. National Institutional and Specialized Accrediting Bodies - Distance Education and Training Council. Retrieved November 14, 2001 from the Department of Education web site: http://www.ed.gov/offices/OPE/accreditation/natlinstandspec.html#det
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. Nationally Recognized Accreditation Agencies. Retrieved November 14, 2001 from the Department of Education web site: http://www.ed.gov/offices/OPE/accreditation/natlagencies.html
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Postsecondary Education. Overview of Accreditation. Retrieved November 14, 2001 from the Department of Education web site: http://www.ed.gov/offices/OPE/accreditation/index.html
Wellman, J. (2000, September 22). Point of view: Accreditors have to see past 'learning outcomes' [Electronic version]. The Chronicle of Higher Education, p. B20.
Western Governors University. About WGU. Retrieved November 25, 2001 from the Western Governors University web site: http://www.wgu.edu/wgu/about/index.html
Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, Western Cooperative for Educational Telecommunications. Regional Accrediting Agency Documents on Electronically Offered Degree and Certificate Programs. Retrieved November 25, 2001 from the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education web site: http://www.wiche.edu/telecom/Article1.htm