Bibliotherapy. ERIC Digest.
by Abdullah, Mardziah Hayati
WHAT IS BIBLIOTHERAPY?
Bibliotherapy generally refers to the use of literature to help people
cope with emotional problems, mental illness, or changes in their lives
(Pardeck, 1994), or to produce affective change and promote personality
growth and development (Lenkowsky, 1987; Adderholdt-Elliott & Eller,
1989). By providing literature relevant to their personal situations and
developmental needs at appropriate times (Hebert & Kent, 2000), bibliotherapy
practitioners attempt to help people of all ages to understand themselves
and to cope with problems such as separation and divorce, child abuse,
foster care, and adoption. This Digest will briefly review the history
of bibliotherapy, summarize some approaches to its application, outline
the basic stages of the bibliotherapeutic process, and will conclude by
reviewing the benefits and limitations which have been observed in its
Historically, bibliotherapy dates back to the 1930s when librarians
began compiling lists of written material that helped individuals modify
their thoughts, feelings, or behaviors for therapeutic purposes. Counselors
worked in conjunction with librarians to 'prescribe' selected literature
for clients experiencing problems (Pardeck, 1994).
The underlying premise of bibliotherapy is that clients identify with
literary characters similar to themselves, an association that helps the
clients release emotions, gain new directions in life, and explore new
ways of interacting (Gladding & Gladding, 1991). Teenage readers, for
example, may feel relief that they are not the only ones facing a specific
problem. They learn vicariously how to solve their problems by reflecting
on how the characters in the book solve theirs (Hebert & Kent, 2000).
SOME APPROACHES IN BIBLIOTHERAPY
Bibliotherapy practice has varied in approach and focus since it was
first used in the 1930s. Traditional bibliotherapy, for example, tended
to be more 'reactive' in its approach in that the process focused on getting
individuals to react positively or negatively to the reading material.
More recent approaches, however, assume that the therapeutic process is
actually a more interactive one: the reader becomes part of the unfolding
intellectual and emotional process of the story, and in struggling to understand
what is being communicated at the deepest levels, the reader responds by
making a positive alternation or modification in behavior or attitude (Myers,
1998). In interactive bibliotherapy, participants engage in activities
that help them reflect on what they read, such as group discussion and
dialogue journal writing (Palmer, et al., 1997; Anderson & MacCurdy,
2000; Morawski & Gilbert, 2000).
In clinical bibliotherapy and bibliocounseling, skilled practitioners
use therapeutic methods to help individuals experiencing serious emotional
problems. Classroom teachers are more likely to use developmental bibliotherapy,
which involves helping students in their normal health and development.
The advantage of the latter approach is that teachers can identify the
concerns of their students and address the issues before problems arise.
Students can also be guided through predictable stages of adolescence with
knowledge of what to expect and examples of how other teenagers have dealt
with the same concerns (Hebert & Kent, 2000).
Whichever approach it involves, bibliotherapy requires careful planning.
It seeks to help clients respond directly to the materials they are given,
so that change is effected through catharsis (a cleansing of the emotions,
primarily through art), insight, or the "copying of character behaviors"
(Gladding & Gladding, 1991).
BASIC STAGES IN BIBLIOTHERAPY
Generally, activities in bibliotherapy are designed to:
* provide information
* provide insight
* stimulate discussion about problems
* communicate new values and attitudes
* create awareness that other people have similar problems
* provide realistic solutions to problems
The process goes through four basic stages (Pardeck, 1993): identification,
selection, presentation, and follow-up.
During the first two stages, the clients' needs must be identified,
and appropriate books selected to match their particular problems. The
selection process takes skill and insight, as the books must provide correct
information about a problem while not imparting a false sense of hope.
The books must then be presented carefully and strategically so that the
clients are able to see similarities between themselves and the book characters.
Once the clients can identify with the main character, they enter the follow-up
stage during which they share what they have gained. They express catharsis
verbally in discussion or writing, or nonverbal means such as art (Sridhar
& Vaughn, 2000), role-playing, creative problem solving, or self-selected
options for students to pursue individually (Hebert & Kent, 2000).
Once catharsis has occurred, the clients can be guided to gain insight
into the problem.
The success of the bibliotherapy program depends largely on how well
teachers or counselors play their vital role as facilitator throughout
the whole process. Sridhar & Vaughn (2000) provide useful ideas on
how teachers can get ready for the process, and what they can do before,
during and after reading.
BENEFITS AND LIMITATIONS OF BIBLIOTHERAPY
In addition to the "how" of conducting bibliotherapy, practitioners
also need to be aware of potential benefits and pitfalls associated with
this procedure. Bibliotherapy has obvious value in that it provides the
opportunity for the participants to recognize and understand themselves,
their characteristics, and the complexity of human thought and behavior.
It may also promote social development as well as the love of literature
in general, and reading in particular (Gladding & Gladding, 1991).
It reduces feelings of isolation that may be felt by people with problems.
The effectiveness of bibliotherapy, however, may be limited by the availability
of materials on certain topics, as well as the lack of client readiness
and willingness to read. Clients may also project their own motives onto
characters and thus reinforce their own perceptions and solutions. In addition,
participants may be defensive, thus discounting the actions of characters
and failing to identify with them, or even end up using them as scapegoats.
Some of these limitations can be overcome through the continuation of the
process itself, role playing, and the use of group discussions (Gladding
& Gladding, 1991). Facilitator limitations are also a challenge: facilitators
may have limited knowledge of human development and developmental problems,
and inadequate knowledge about appropriate literature. Facilitators thus
need to be properly trained and exposed to a repertoire of literature suitable
for use in bibliotherapy. One other limitation may lie in the bibliotherapy
process itself: for example, clients may be unwilling to discuss areas
that are uncomfortable, or facilitators may insist on making a point at
the client's expense. The process is also limited if both the client and
counselor stay on surface issues. These limitations can be addressed by
suspending sessions until both parties are ready and willing to work, by
taping and critiquing selected sessions so that facilitators can monitor
their own reactions to certain clients or problem areas, and by revisiting
issues in stories that have been treated superficially in previous sessions
(Gladding & Gladding, 1991).
Bibliotherapy is a potentially powerful method for school teachers and
counselors to use on many levels and in every school grade. In order to
establish a strong bibliotherapy program in an institution, practitioners
must present the procedure as a non-threatening one, starting by calling
the process biblioguidance, for instance. They must also solicit the input
and advice of colleagues, parents, and administrators. In addition, they
must always be alert to the limitations of bibliotherapy.
Adderholdt-Elliott, M. & Eler, S. H. (1989).Counseling students
who are gifted through bibliotherapy. Teaching Exceptional Children. 22(1),
26-31. [EJ 399 150]
Anderson, C. M. & MacCurdy, M. M. (2000). Writing and healing: Toward
an informed practice. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English.
[ED 436 788]
Gladding, S. T. & Gladding, C. (1991). The ABCs of bibliotherapy
for school counselors. School Counselor, 39(1), 7-13. [EJ 435 466]
Hebert, T. P. & Kent, R. (2000). Nurturing social and emotional
development in gifted teenagers through young adult literature. Roeper
Review, 22(3), p167-171. [EJ 606 610]
Lenkowsky, R. S. (1987). Bibliotherapy: A review and analysis of the
literature. Journal of Special Education, 2(2), 123-32. [EJ 361 026]
Morawski, C. M. & Gilbert, J. N. (2000). Developmental interactive
bibliotherapy. College Teaching, 48(3), 108-114. [EJ 614 996]
Myers, J. E. (1998). Bibliotherapy and DCT: Co-constructing the therapeutic
metaphor. Journal of Counseling and Development, 76(3), 243-250. [EJ 573
Palmer, B. C.; Biller, D. L.; Rancourt, R. E.; & Teets, K. A. (1997).
Interactive bibliotherapy: An effective method for healing and empowering
emotionally-abused women. Journal of Poetry Therapy, 11(1), 3-15. [EJ 559
Pardeck, J. T. (1993). Literature and adoptive children with disabilities.
Early Child Development and Care. 91, 33-39. [EJ 473 213]
Pardeck, J.T. (1994). Using literature to help adolescents cope with
problems. Adolescence, 29(114), 421-427. [EJ 487 572]
Sridhar, D. & Vaughn, S. (2000). Bibliotherapy for all. Teaching
Exceptional Children, 33(2), 74-82. [EJ 614 798]