ERIC Identifier: ED350488
Publication Date: 1992-00-00
Author: Wonacott, Michael E.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Adult Career and Vocational Education Columbus OH.
Career Education and Applied Academics. ERIC Digest No. 128.
Career education is a concept that originated in the early 1970s. As
explained by one of the field's original theorists, the premise of career
education was that schools should "use the entire educational experience to
better prepare youth for career success in the full range of occupations while
using the potential relevance of academic learning as a motivator for
educational success" (Mangum 1992, pp. 31-32). Career education is intended to
prepare each individual for career development--that is, to select and engage in
productive, satisfying work throughout life.
Perhaps the most essential element of career education is the close link it
espouses between education and work. In its broadest sense, career development
seeks to answer fundamental questions about education and work for each
individual (Terry and Hargis forthcoming): "What do I do with my life? How much
education do I need? What satisfactions do I want from my work? What skills can
I develop? What level of income do I hope to have? How do I change careers?" The
goal of career education is to provide the individual with the knowledge and
skills needed to answer those questions.
Thus, it could be said that career education is but one more chapter in the
historical debate over the merits of a liberal education versus a technical
education. Herr (1987) traces this debate back to the nation's founders,
contrasting Franklin's preference for a pragmatic, utilitarian education with
Jefferson's belief that possession of basic academic skills equipped one to move
into almost any realm. It could also be said that career education espouses an
approach midway between a liberal and a technical education: Although the value
of theoretical knowledge for its own sake cannot be denied, and although
specific occupational knowledge and skills are certainly needed, no less
necessary are the basic academic skills, an understanding of their relevance to
the workplace, and specific knowledge about the world of work and individual
IS CAREER EDUCATION STILL RELEVANT TODAY?
In many respects,
career education has never been needed more than it is today. The ever-faster
pace of technological change and the increased competitiveness of workplaces and
economies around the globe have challenged the nation's ability to maintain the
world's highest standard of living. According to the Secretary's Commission on
Achieving Necessary Skills (SCANS 1991), a strong back, eager hands, and a high
school diploma used to be enough to get a job, keep it, and make it into a
career. No more--now the need to keep abreast of technological change and to
participate effectively in today's high-performance workplace require each
worker to possess a set of basic competencies and a foundation of skills and
personal qualities (ibid., p. vii):
Basic competency areas:
Resources--allocating time, money, materials, space, and staff
Interpersonal skills--working on teams, teaching others, serving customers,
leading, negotiating, and working well with people from culturally diverse
Information--acquiring and evaluating data, organizing and maintaining files,
interpreting and communicating, and using computers to process information
Systems--understanding social, organizational, and technological systems;
monitoring and correcting performance; and designing or improving systems
Technology--selecting equipment and tools, applying technology to specific
tasks, and maintaining and troubleshooting technologies
Foundation skills and qualities:
Basic skills--reading, writing, mathematics, speaking, and listening
Thinking skills--thinking creatively, making decisions, solving problems,
knowing how to learn, and reasoning
Personal qualities--responsibility, self-esteem, sociability, self-management,
A further SCANS report (1992) spells out the implications for educators who
wish to provide their students with such competencies and foundation skills: (1)
teaching should be offered in context--"learning to know" should not be
separated from "learning to do"; (2) improving the match between what work
requires and what students are taught requires changing how instruction is
delivered and how students learn; (3) high performance requires a new system of
school administration and assessment; and (4) the entire community must be
Explicitly or implicitly, the SCANS competencies, foundation, and
implications encompass two key tenets of career education:
Infusion--Prerequisite knowledge and skills needed in the world of work should
not be taught in isolation; rather, they should be infused throughout the
curriculum. Career information, career decision-making skills, academic basic
skills, technological skills, information skills, and interpersonal skills
should pervade all of education.
Careers emphasis--Students must be able to see the direct relevance of
instruction to their own future in the world of work. Such visible relevance
helps increase both motivation and learning (Terry and Hargis forthcoming).
WHAT ARE EFFECTIVE CAREER EDUCATION TECHNIQUES?
principles of infusion and career emphasis are critical in developing the work
force. Although not specifically termed infusion, the following career programs
incorporate the concepts of integration of academic and vocational education and
can make vital contributions in preparing workers for the changing workplace.
Career information and guidance systems. Information on careers and
counseling in making a suitable career choice are critical components of the
transition from education to employment. A survey by the Council of Chief State
School Officers (1991) reports a variety of career information and guidance
systems across the nation that focus on these objectives:
Helping students evaluate their abilities and interests
Providing guidance on education requirements for occupations of interest
(including nontraditional careers)
Providing students with up-to-date labor market information
Using guidance, academic, and vocational education personnel for counseling
Informing parents about course requirements for employment or postsecondary
Providing job placement assistance
State systems such as the Oregon Career Information System are typically
designed to meet the National Career Development Guidelines of the National
Occupational Information Coordinating Committee (Oregon Occupational Information
Coordinating Committee 1989).
Youth apprenticeship. An increasing number of youth apprenticeship programs
enable secondary students to enter apprenticeships conducted jointly by local
schools and businesses (William T. Grant Foundation 1991). Students enrolled in
youth apprenticeship programs typically receive on-the-job training at the
workplace and related theoretical instruction in the school classroom. Such
programs enjoy all the advantages of work-based approaches to education: a
hands-on approach, instruction based on real work tasks, and mentoring and
instruction by skilled practitioners.
Youth community service. A national movement is also underway to provide
youth with opportunities for community service. Such community service programs
are believed to provide youth with an enhanced sense of self-worth and good
citizenship and to increase the relevance of learning (William T. Grant
Foundation 1991). Over 3,000 community service programs are operated in public
and private schools across the United States; more than 450 college campuses
have programs to encourage community service; and 55 year-round service or
conservation corps and 20 summer youth corps enroll about 20,000 youth.
Career-oriented secondary school programs and curricula. Mitchell et al.
(1990) identified a number of urban high schools that have great success in
preparing at-risk students for specific occupational fields as well as for
college entrance. Factors common across all the programs include a safe and
orderly environment, a businesslike attitude among students and teachers, high
expectations of all students, and strong linkages with business and industry,
among others. Such programs can serve as models for other educators serving
Similar success has been achieved by other efforts to develop integrated,
career-oriented curricula for both vocational and academic subjects. One example
is the Educational Excellence through Career-Vocational Education project
(Leising et al. 1989), which provided technical assistance, guidance, and
inservice programs to reshape school philosophies, develop comprehensive
guidance plans, and review curriculum in all areas. Among the outcomes of the
project were these: dropout rates decreased from 16 to 11 percent; attendance
rates increased by 1.8 percent; teen pregnancies dropped by 50 percent; and
suspension days decreased by 84 percent.
Tech prep. Another new approach to education is the tech prep concept--a
continuum of articulated course offerings spanning the last 2 years of high
school and the first 2 years of college (William T. Grant Foundation 1991, pp.
25-28). Tech prep programs typically include a strong career counseling
component, genuine school-college collaboration and articulation, applied
academics in basic subjects, and extensive involvement of local employers. Many
states are setting up requirements for tech-prep programs, following the lead of
the federal Carl D. Perkins Vocational and Applied Technology Education Act of
HOW CAN THE BENEFITS OF CAREER EDUCATION BE MAXIMIZED?
benefits of career education can probably best be maximized by working with
educators in other disciplines. Not all educators are aware of the advantages of
career education for their students--and for themselves. Academic educators need
to understand, for example, that career education is not a threat to their
disciplines; rather, it is a powerful tool that they can use to gain the
interest of students. They need to understand that teaching academic skills in a
careers context makes their curriculum more relevant to their students,
increasing both motivation and learning. After all, geometry can be dry when
applied to conceptual triangles, but it is less so when applied to actual
triangles in the real world--like those found in bridges, buildings, football
formations, roof trusses, freeway ramps, engine brackets, beveled edges, and
Council of Chief State School Officers. STATE
INITIATIVES FOR SCHOOL AND THE WORKPLACE. Washington, DC: Council of Chief State
School Officers, 1991.
Herr, E. L. "Education as Preparation for Work: Contributions of Career
Education and Vocational Education." JOURNAL OF CAREER DEVELOPMENT 13, no. 3
(Spring 1987): 16-30. (EJ 353 450)
Leising, J.; Emo, W.; Olivier, P.; and Verloo, N. A GUIDE TO UNDERSTANDING THE EDUCATIONAL EXCELLENCE THROUGH CAREER-VOCATIONAL EDUCATION PROJECT. Davis: University of California; Sacramento: California Department of Education, 1989. (ED 333
Mangum, S. L. "Career Education: An Opportunity Lost." FUTURE CHOICES 3, no.
2 (1992): 31-38.
Mitchell, V.; Russell, E. S.; Benson, C. S.; Chambers, J. G.; and Just, A. E.
EXEMPLARY URBAN CAREER-ORIENTED SECONDARY SCHOOL PROGRAMS. Berkeley: National
Center for Research in Vocational Education, University of California, Berkeley,
1990. (ED 325 623)
Oregon Occupational Information Coordinating Committee. SCHOOLWORK, LIFEWORK: INTEGRATING CAREER INFORMATION INTO HIGH SCHOOL CAREER DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS. Salem: Oregon Occupational Information Coordinating Committee; Eugene: Oregon Career Information System, 1989. (ED 323 340)
Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary Skills. WHAT WORK REQUIRES OF
SCHOOLS. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor, 1991. (ED 332 054)
Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary Skills. LEARNING A LIVING: A BLUEPRINT FOR HIGH PERFORMANCE. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor, 1992. (ED 346 348)
Terry, Arthur F., and Hargis, Nancy. CAREER EDUCATION REVISITED: IMPLICATIONS
FOR THE 1990S. Columbus: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult, Career, and Vocational
William T. Grant Foundation. STATES AND COMMUNITIES ON THE MOVE: POLICY INITIATIVES TO CREATE A WORLD-CLASS WORKFORCE. Washington, DC: William T. Grant Foundation Commission on Work, Family and Citizenship, 1991. (ED 339 875)