ERIC Identifier: ED343408
Publication Date: 1991-12-00
Author: Wilcox, Sherman - Wilcox, Phyllis
Clearinghouse on Languages and Linguistics Washington DC.
Teaching ASL as a Second Language. ERIC Digest.
This Digest is based on the monograph, "Learning to See: American Sign
Language as a Second Language" (1991), available from Regents Prentice Hall,
Mail Order Processing, 200 Old Tappan Road, Old Tappan, NJ 07675 (201) 767-5937.
Interest in American Sign Language (ASL) is at an all-time high. Throughout
the 1980s, ASL programs were established on college campuses and in high schools
across the country. As soon as one course was established, there were enough
students to fill two. If two classes were opened, enough students showed up to
The sudden popularity and acceptance of a previously neglected language was
heartening for language teachers who had been in the field of ASL for many
years. The field was not fully prepared, however, to meet the rapidly increasing
demand for ASL instruction. There were few teacher training programs; there was
a paucity of instructional materials, no standard curricula, little or no
literature on teaching ASL as a second language, and no accreditation procedures
for ASL programs or teachers.
To help ASL teachers and administrators design and implement effective ASL
programs, this Digest answers questions about ASL and the essential components
of an ASL program, including ASL course design, methods and approaches for
teaching ASL as a second language, and ASL instructional materials.
HOW IS ASL DIFFERENT FROM FOREIGN LANGUAGES LIKE SPANISH AND
Because of its signed modality, people often assume that ASL is
fundamentally different from spoken languages, or that it is merely a contrived
representation of English. In reality, ASL is a fully developed, natural
language. It is not a derivative of English; ASL contains structures and
processes that English does not (Klima & Bellugi, 1979). ASL is a complete
language with its own unique grammar (Fromkin, 1988). It is a true human
language, with all the features of other human languages. An abstract concept
can be expressed in ASL as easily as in English, Spanish, Navajo, or any other
The acceptance of ASL in fulfillment of foreign language requirements is
being debated in school districts, universities, and state legislatures across
the country. ASL is not foreign in a geopolitical sense--it is indigenous to the
United States and parts of Canada. Other indigenous languages, such as Navajo,
are generally accepted in fulfillment of a foreign language requirement. If the
purpose of foreign language study is to introduce students to a language and
culture they do not already know--that is, a language and culture that are
foreign to their experience--ASL qualifies admirably.
WHAT ARE THE MAIN COMPONENTS OF AN ASL PROGRAM?
to ASL language courses, where students learn to communicate using ASL, an ASL
program should include a holistic introductory course about ASL and deafness, an
ASL linguistics course, and a course in Deaf culture.
* "Holistic introductory course." Beginning students of ASL usually need to
unlearn stereotyped myths and misconceptions about ASL and deafness. They need a
"safe" environment in which to ask questions, in spoken English, about deafness,
the Deaf community, hearing-impaired individuals, and the use of signed
* "ASL linguistics." This course should be offered soon after students have
begun to acquire syntactic, pragmatic, and semantic concepts in the ASL
classroom. It should include a discussion of the basic phonological and
morphological aspects of ASL, which are, of course, visual/gestural rather than
aural/oral. It is also important for ASL students to be aware of the major
sociolinguistic issues in the Deaf community, such as the variation and language
outcome resulting from contact between ASL and English.
* "Deaf culture." Respect for and understanding of Deaf culture should be
cultivated in the classroom. Some of the Deaf cultural mores and behaviors that
can be taught include introductions, leave-taking, conversational turn-taking,
language code-switching, criteria for acceptance or non-acceptance in the
culture, folklore, group norms, identity, and so forth.
WHAT TEACHING METHODS WORK BEST WITH ASL?
In recent years,
ASL programs and teachers have begun to apply recognized methodological
strategies from the second language learning field to the teaching of ASL.
Various methodologies and approaches can be used.
"Signing Naturally," a widely-used standardized ASL curriculum developed by
Vista Community College (CA) with funding from the U.S. Department of
Education's Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education, is based on the
"functional/notional" approach. This approach places major emphasis on the
communicative purpose of speech acts--or "functions"--of a language: introducing
people to one another, requesting information, extending an invitation,
directing someone to do or not to do something, describing a book, and so forth.
Other effective approaches, many of which are used as substrategies by the
"Signing Naturally" program, include the following:
* "Role playing" can be used to promote simplified interactive exchanges
between students. The speed of signing, although fluent, is recognizably slower
than normal conversation between ASL native signers.
* "Episodic hypothesis" suggests that any text or discourse will be easier to
recall and understand if it is episodically organized (Oller &
Richard-Amato, 1983). An episodic lesson can be as simple as having students
describe what they see in a picture, what they think happened immediately before
the picture, and what happened immediately thereafter. Discussion focuses not
only on the correct usage of ASL, but also on the story sequencing.
* The "cognitive approach" attempts to organize materials around a
grammatical syllabus while allowing for meaningful practice and use of language
(Richards & Rodgers, 1986). It emphasizes understanding and encourages the
conscious selection of grammatical forms.
* "Spiraling" assists students in acquiring language concepts. "Materials or
skills are taught in increasingly greater depth at each succeeding level of
instruction" (Baker & Cokely, 1980, p. 183).
Some methods of second language instruction include a silent period during
which the learners are not required to speak and are allowed to rehearse
silently. ASL courses frequently offer visual preparation exercises before
expecting students to produce signs accurately. Hearing students are auditorily
attuned to their environment and need a transition period to help them become
Most language acquisition and teaching theorists now support a holistic view
of second language learning in which teachers are sensitive to the individual
needs of students rather than to any dominant language methodology (Finocchiaro
& Brumfit, 1983). Before deciding which approaches to use, ASL teachers,
like all second language teachers, should learn who their students are and why
they want to learn the language.
WHAT KINDS OF INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS ARE USED TO TEACH
To be truly effective, ASL programs should have high-quality video
recording and playback facilities, a video language lab equipped with a large
collection of ASL and Deaf culture videotapes, and facilities for students to
view tapes on an individual basis. Other materials required are much the same as
those needed in any language program.
* "Texts." The National Association of the Deaf and T. J. Publishers offer
several excellent textbooks for ASL. (For a comprehensive list, see Wilcox &
* "Videotapes." An excellent functional/notional approach to teaching ASL is
provided in the "Signing Naturally" tape. Locally produced videotapes can be a
good resource to supplement the ASL curriculum with local signed dialects and
conversational topics not provided by commercially produced videotapes.
* "Objects and pictures." Objects and pictures provide non-linguistic means
of comprehension and encourage the use of "here-and-now" language. Examples
include pictures of objects and actions; sequenced story line pictures; tinker
toy construction sets (for teaching size and shape classifiers); building blocks
of various shapes and colors; objects representing animals and people; and maps
of countries and local geographical areas.
* "Flash cards." Handshape flash cards can be used in exercises at the
phonological level (Bahan & Paul, 1984), and in breakaway exercises during a
class or lab session.
* "Computers." Interactive videodisc has tremendous potential for use in ASL
classrooms. Integrated combinations of hardware and software link images stored
on a videodisc to a computer that is used to store the locations of video
segments, do complex searches based on the student's input, and play the
selected portion of the disc (Ambron & Hooper, 1990).
The study of ASL as a second language can be a
culturally and linguistically rewarding experience. However, careful planning is
essential to the development of an effective ASL program. There are many
important considerations involved that have not been discussed here due to space
limitations. These include teacher training, program administration, student
assessment, and program articulation from the secondary to university levels.
Detailed discussion of these issues can be found in Wilcox & Wilcox (1991)
and in the other resources listed below.
Ambron, S., & Hooper, K. (1990). "Learning
with interactive multimedia: Developing and using multimedia tools in
education." Redmond, WA: Microsoft Press.
Bahan, B., & Paul , F. (1984). "American Sign Language handshape cards."
Berkeley, CA: Dawn Sign Press.
Baker, C., & Cokely, D. (1980). "American Sign Language: A teacher's
resource test on curriculum, methods, and evaluation." Silver Spring, MD: T. J.
Finocchiaro, M., & Brumfit, C. (1983). "The functional-notional approach:
From theory to practice." New York: Oxford University Press.
Fromkin, V.A. (1988). Sign languages: Evidence for language universals and
the linguistic capacity of the human brain. "Sign Language Studies, 59,"
Klima, E., & Bellugi, U. (1979). "The signs of language." Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
Oller, J., & Richard-Amato, P. (Eds.). (1983). "Some working ideas for
language teaching. Methods that work: A smorgasbord of ideas for language
teachers." Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
Richards, J., & Rodgers, T. (1986). "Approaches and methods in language
teaching: A description and analysis." New York: Cambridge University Press.
Wilcox, S., & Wilcox, P. (1991). "Learning to see: American Sign Language
as a second language." Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Regents Prentice Hall/Center for