ERIC Identifier: ED357333
Publication Date: 1993-00-00
Author: Aiex, Nola Kortner
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Reading and Communication Skills Bloomington IN.
Bibliotherapy. ERIC Digest.
Simply stated, bibliotherapy can be defined as the use of books to help
people solve problems. Another, more precise definition is that bibliotherapy is
a family of technique for structuring interaction between a facilitator and a
participant based on mutual sharing of literature (Pardeck, 1989).
The idea of healing through books is not a new one--it can be traced far back
in history, from the days of the first libraries in Greece (Bibliotherapy,
1982). The use of books in healing, however, has been interpreted differently by
classical scholars, physicians, psychologists, social workers, nurses, parents,
teachers, librarians, and counselors. There is, in fact, confusion in
determining the dividing line between reading guidance and bibliotherapy (Smith,
1989). And the vast amount of professional literature that is available on
bibliotherapy (Eppele, 1989) naturally mirrors the point of view of the helping
professional who wrote it and the field in which he or she is an expert.
DOES IT WORK?
Riordan and Wilson (1989), in a review of the
literature of the effects of bibliotherapy, found that a majority of the studies
show mixed results for the efficacy of bibliotherapy as a separate treatment for
the solving of problems. They concluded that bibliotherapy generally appears to
be more successful as an adjunctive therapy. Despite such mixed research
results, however, interest in the use of bibliotherapy appears to have increased
in the past few years. This most likely reflects the increase of societal and
familial problems in the United States--rise in divorce, alienation of young
people, excessive peer group pressure, alcohol and drug abuse, and so on.
Educators have also begun to recognize the increasingly critical need for
delivering literacy instruction to at-risk and homeless children and their
families (Ouzts, 1991).
In addition, researchers Riordan and Wilson concluded that the explosion of
self-help programs during the past decade has contributed to the rise in the use
of bibliotherapy, in the form of popular self-help books, such as "What Color Is
Your Parachute" and "The Relaxation Response." Books such as these are the
prescriptive choice of most mental health professionals for their clients,
rather than fiction or poetry, according to the two researchers. Is self-help
(even directed self-help) really bibliotherapy? This popular practice
underscores the confusion about defining the actual technique of bibliotherapy
mentioned at the beginning of this digest.
WHEN SHOULD BIBLIOTHERAPY BE USED?
intervention may be undertaken for many reasons: (1) to develop an individual's
self-concept; (2) to increase an individual's understanding of human behavior or
motivations; (3) to foster an individual's honest self-appraisal; (4) to provide
a way for a person to find interests outside of self; (5) to relieve emotional
or mental pressure; (6) to show an individual that he or she is not the first or
only person to encounter such a problem; (7) to show an individual that there is
more than one solution to a problem; (8) to help a person discuss a problem more
freely; and (9) to help an individual plan a constructive course of action to
solve a problem.
Before undertaking bibliotherapy, however, a practitioner must remember that
it is more than just the casual recommendation of a certain book to an
individual--it is a deliberate course of action that requires careful planning
WHO SHOULD CONDUCT BIBLIOTHERAPY?
Whether you are a
classroom teacher, a librarian, or a mental health professional, be advised that
bibliotherapy must be handled with great delicacy, and not every practitioner
possesses the personal qualifications to be a facilitator in the process. Those
who are interested, however, should possess personal stability; a genuine
interest in working with others; and the ability to empathize with others
without moralizing, threatening, or commanding (Bibliotherapy, 1982).
In addition, Smith (1989) recommends working with another practitioner or
authority in a different field. For example, if you are a language arts teacher,
you might collaborate with the school librarian, a guidance counselor, or the
school psychologist. This cooperation helps in balancing the process so that no
one person is "in charge." Smith also feels that facilitators need to have a
light-enough tone in discussing problems so that no one becomes upset, but a
thoughtful-enough manner to allow for "comfortable discussion." She also feels
that fictional works are best for discussion purposes because participants can
talk about the characters in a book rather than about themselves (Smith, 1989).
All parties must agree to the bibliotherapy, however. A recent study on
generating reading interest in adolescents with handicaps (Klemens, 1993) found
that the majority were not even interested in reading novels with handicapped
characters. Most of the young people in the survey "seemed to view the term
'handicapped' in a very narrow sense and reject the word and anything to which
it may be connected."
HOW SHOULD IT BE USED?
Arleen Hynes's book, "Bibliotherapy
Handbook," is considered a good all-around introduction to bibliotherapy. It
defines the types of bibliotherapy and details what the practitioner needs to
know, including basic information on how to become a bibliotherapist (Smith,
Above all, books chosen by the practitioner should have literary merit--a
poorly written novel with stereotyped characters and simplistic answers to
complex questions is probably worse than not reading anything at all and can
even leave children or young people with a negative view of literature. Reading
quality literature, however, can be beneficial to students, even outside the
context of bibliotherapy (White, 1989). A classroom teacher who really loves
literature and who has a large collection of books is in a good position to
conduct bibliotherapy, if he or she possesses the other necessary personal
A practitioner must also decide whether an individual or a group therapy
approach would be best in the particular situation. Individual therapy requires
time-consuming one-on-one sessions, but some people feel freer to express
themselves in a one-on-one situation.
For a classroom teacher, of course, the classroom could be seen as a natural
group, and it would be a group easily broken up into collaborative units.
According to Pardeck and Pardeck (1990), groups can be a powerful vehicle for
helping to heal emotional problems. The Pardecks believe that a group approach
to learning enhances the total child. The group approach allows members to share
common experiences, thus lessening anxieties. It can create a feeling of
belonging and can also provide security for individuals who might feel
uncomfortable in situations where they are singled out for special attention.
Working in a group may lead an individual to develop a different perspective and
a new understanding of the problems of others (Bibliotherapy, 1982).
Regardless of whether the practitioner chooses
the individual or group approach, the basic procedures in conducting
bibliotherapy are: (1) motivate the individual or individuals with introductory
activities; (2) provide time for reading the material; (3) allow incubation
time; (4) provide follow-up discussion time, using questions that will lead
persons from literal recall of information through interpretation, application,
analysis, synthesis, and evaluation of that information; and (5) conduct
evaluation and direct the individual or individuals toward closure--this
involves both evaluation by the practitioner and self-evaluation by the
individual (Bibliotherapy, 1982).
Bibliotherapy. Fact Sheet (1982). Urbana, IL:
ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and Communication Skills. [ED 234 338]
Eppele, Ruth (1989). Reading Material Selection: K-12. Focused Access to
Selected Topics (FAST) Bibliography No. 30. Bloomington, IN: ERIC Clearinghouse
on Reading and Communication Skills. [ED 311 394]
Klemens, Lynne (1993). Are Handicapped Adolescents Interested in Reading
Fiction with Handicapped Characters? M.A. Thesis, Kean College. [CS 011 232]
Ouzts, Dan T. (1991). "The Emergence of Bibliotherapy as a Discipline."
Reading Horizons, 31(3), 199-206. [EJ 421 220]
Pardeck, John T. and Jean A. Pardeck (1990). "Using Developmental Literature
with Collaborative Groups." Reading Improvement, 27(4), 226-37. [EJ 421 176]
Pardeck, John T. and Jean A. Pardeck (1989). "Bibliotherapy: A Tool for
Helping Preschool Children Deal with Developmental Change Related to Family
Relationships." Early Child Development and Care, 47, 107-29. [EJ 401 179]
Riordan, Richard J. and Linda S. Wilson (1989). Bibliotherapy: Does It Work?"
Journal of Counseling and Development, 67(9). [EJ 396 292]
Smith, Alice G. (1989). "Will the Real Bibliotherapist Please Stand Up?"
Journal of Youth Services in Libraries, 2(3), 241-49. [EJ 395 489]
White, Richard (1989). Bibliotherapy and the Reluctant Student. [ED 309 390]