ERIC Identifier: ED355311
Publication Date: 1992-12-00
Author: Burnett, Gary
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban
Education New York NY.
Career Academies: Educating Urban Students for Career Success.
ERIC/CUE Digest, Number 84.
Recently it has been recognized that many schools have not educated
non-college bound students well. Even those students who do finish high school
are frequently underprepared for the growing cognitive demands of the modern
workplace, and dropout rates remain high. Thus, a significant percentage of the
workforce is hard-pressed to meet even the minimum requirements of
employability. Career academies have been developed as a school restructuring
tool intended to address these problems: to help cut dropout rates, to improve
student performance, and to equip students to face the complexities of future
The first career academy--the Electrical
Academy--was created in 1969 in Philadelphia at the Thomas Edison High School,
which had the highest dropout rate in the city (Neubauer, 1986). By 1991, eight
programs in 16 high schools were in place in Philadelphia (Stern, Raby, & Dayton, 1992). In 1981, the model was exported to California, where it became
the basis for the Peninsula Academies in the Sequoia Union High School District
south of San Francisco. Between 1985 and 1987, this program--now called the
California partnership academies and supported by state legislation and
funding--spread throughout the state (Stern et al., 1992). By 1992, academies
had been established focusing on 20 different career fields, including
agribusiness, communication and video technology, finance, environmental
technology, and transportation (Stern et al., 1992).
THE ACADEMY MODEL
Since most career academies around the
country were modeled upon the Philadelphia and Peninsula efforts, they share a
number of attributes. In general, they:
are organized as schools-within-schools, with a small community of students and
a small, self-contained set of five to ten counselors and teachers, one of whom
acts as the program's "lead teacher";
recruit students to volunteer for the program;
focus on broadly-defined career themes--such as computers, electronics, or
health--rather than on the job-specific outlines of traditional vocational
choose career areas with growing demands and with good employment opportunities
in the local market;
integrate academic and vocational curricula and use block-scheduling to keep
students together in unified groups throughout the day and throughout the entire
three- or four-year program;
eliminate tracking by setting rigorous academic courses into the context of
occupational training, giving students the option to continue their education
make work experience a component of the educational process by systematically
exposing students to job interviews and issues of work ethics and behavior;
are sustained by high levels of involvement by local business, as well as strong
parental support; and
receive significant outside funding, from both business and government sources
(Stern et al., 1992; Dayton, Weisberg, & Stern, 1989).
In addition, students in the academies must meet all state and local
requirements for graduation.
One of the strongest features of the academy model is its curricular and
pedagogical coordination. Not only does it integrate academic and vocational
courses--preparing students for college as well as for careers--but the
academy's small size allows an uncommon measure of collaboration between
teachers. In the California academies students take four classes as a group
every semester--usually three academic and one technical. Because the academy's
teachers are a self-contained group, they share a common planning period every
day, are able to design carefully interrelated lesson plans, and can coordinate
Since academy students progress as a group, classes from the beginning to the
end of the entire three- or four-year program can be designed as a sequence
rather than as a grab-bag of unrelated units (Stern et al., 1992). Such
program-wide coordination, enhanced by the academy's small size and cohesive
student body, allows the creation of strong career development programs. It also
generates consistently high expectations for student success (Archer, Weinbaum,
& Montesano, 1989). All classes--technical as well as academic--combine the
cognitive rigor of academies with the hands-on orientation of vocational
CAREER ACADEMY PARTICIPANTS
Career academies have, for the
most part, emerged in urban districts, where dropping out and unemployment have
been particularly acute. As a result, their primary intent has been to serve
students at risk of leaving high school (Archer et al., 1989; Stern et al.,
1992). Many students recruited for academies have come from poor backgrounds,
have poor attendance and grades, and have amassed insufficient course credits.
In the California program during the 1987-88 school year, academies were almost
evenly divided between males and females, and contained comparatively high
percentages of African American and Latino students (Dayton, Weisberg, & Stern, 1989).
An important feature of career academies is that students attend by choice;
though they may be recruited, they must fill out an admissions application.
Thus, they must demonstrate a strong commitment to the academy, and they tend to
develop a high degree of pride and a sense of belonging. In recent years,
academies have attracted a broader cross-section of students interested in a
career. This suggests that the academy model has potential beyond its original
function as a dropout prevention measure, although care must be taken that
academies do not begin to "cream" the best students away from their host
schools, leaving those schools to deal with large numbers of disadvantaged
students (Stern et al., 1992).
The voluntary nature of academies extends
to faculty and administration. Like other restructuring models, academies thrive
on the presence of a director with a clear vision of their importance.
Similarly, because they depend upon a tightly-knit faculty, academies should be
staffed by dedicated teacher volunteers. Appointed teachers often lack
commitment to the model; their presence may lead to a high turnover rate,
subverting the collegial atmosphere required by academies.
BUSINESS INVOLVEMENT IN ACADEMIES
From the beginning,
academies have benefited from a high level of business involvement. Such
participation may take the form of financial support to help offset the high
costs of academies, especially during the start-up phase (Archer et al., 1989).
More commonly, however, businesses take a hands-on approach, providing not only
summer and afterschool jobs, but also volunteering speakers, mentors, and even
teachers (Stern et al., 1992). In fact, because the success of an academy
depends upon its links with the business community, extensive collaboration
between the schools and local business is built into the model from the earliest
planning stages. Business participation is carefully planned to coordinate with
both academic and vocational instruction. This integration of business and
education can give students not only work experience, but also an invaluable
introduction to the job market and workplace culture.
School restructuring projects require
careful, ongoing evaluation (Archer et al., 1989). Because the California
academies have been replicated throughout the state, they have profited from
such analysis, required by the legislation allowing their proliferation. Though
this analysis is somewhat hampered by the lack of a truly experimental
random-assignment method of assigning students to the academies, it has found
that the schools do have a positive impact on keeping students in school, as
well as upon the future employment and education of graduates (Stern et al.,
Reports on the Peninsula Academies suggest features important for new career
academies. They must maintain:
strict adherence to the full career academy model;
a clearly defined process for selecting students and ensuring that the program
strong support from the private sector;
an emphasis on career planning;
a full range of student support services such as counseling and mentoring
a high degree of commitment from teachers, administrators, and the business
an identifiable physical space for the academy, to reinforce students' sense of
belonging (Dayton, Reller, & Evans, 1987).
Because academies require the active participation of local business--and
because their career themes are geared toward local employment
possibilities--they should reflect the cultural and economic features of the the
areas in which they are established (Stern et al., 1992).
As restructuring tools, career academies require
a significant financial investment. Not only are their start-up costs high, but
their reliance upon small communities of students and teachers makes the
per-student price higher in comparison to traditional schools--an important
consideration in districts facing budget cuts (Archer et al., 1989). However,
studies factoring in the societal costs associated with continuing high dropout
rates show that the long-term benefits far outweigh the investments required by
academies (Stern, Dayton, Paik, & Weisberg, 1989). As an educational and
vocational operation, career academies may be a long-term bargain.
Archer, E., Weinbaum, S., & Montesano, P.
(1989). Partnerships for learning: School completion and employment preparation
in the high school academies. New York: Academy for Educational Development. (ED
Dayton, C., Reller, D., & Evans, J. (1987). Peninsula academies
replications: 1985-86 evaluation report. Berkeley: University of California,
Policy Analysis for California Education. (ED 293 929)
Dayton, C., Weisberg, A., & Stern, D. (1989). California partnership
academies: 1987-88 evaluation report (Policy Paper No. PP 89-9-1). Berkeley:
University of California, Policy Analysis for California Education. (ED 327 602)
Neubauer, A. (1986). Philadelphia high school academies. Educational
Horizons, 65(1), 16-19.
Stern, D., Dayton, C., Paik, I., & Weisberg, A. (1989). Benefits and
costs of dropout prevention in a high school program combining academic and
vocational education: Third-year results from replications of the California
peninsula academies. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 11(4), 405-416.
Stern, D., Raby, M., & Dayton, C. (1992). Career academies: Partnerships
for reconstructing American high schools. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
This digest is based on a paper prepared for the National Center of Research
in Vocational Education, "Building the Middle." To order the paper, please
contact NCRVE, University of California, 1995 University Avenue, Suite 375,
Berkeley, CA 97404.