ERIC Identifier: ED376274
Publication Date: 1994-00-00
Author: Imel, Susan
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult
Career and Vocational Education Columbus OH.
Job Search Skills for the Current Economy. ERIC Digest No. 150.
Despite the fact that the United States is creating about 2 million new jobs
per year, unemployment and underemployment continue to be a way of life for many
individuals (Church 1993). Particularly at risk are middle managers and college
graduates. Since 1988, 19 percent of the layoffs have been from the ranks of
those classified as middle managers, more than any other group, and Fortune 500
companies continue to announce cutbacks. The Department of Labor projects that
between now and 2005, nearly 30 percent of college graduates will be under- or
unemployed, compared to 19.9 percent in 1990 (Topolnicki 1993). These changing
economic conditions have altered conventional practices for finding a job. Both
new college graduates and seasoned workers are discovering that traditional job
search methods can no longer be counted on to result in satisfactory employment.
This ERIC Digest provides information about effective, contemporary job search
strategies through a discussion of the current context, general information
about the job search process, and strategies for those job seekers most at risk.
THE CURRENT CONTEXT
The most recent recession that began in
July 1990 and ended officially in March 1991 was mild compared to previous
recessions, but it harshly affected the U.S. work force. Not only did the labor
market continue to deteriorate long after the recession officially ended, but
also white-collar workers were more at risk of losing their jobs in the early
1990s than at any time in the past (Gardner 1994). Several recent events
indicate that the labor market is recovering from the 1990-1991 recession:
--In 1993, the economy created more jobs than it
eliminated, with most in managerial, professional, and technical occupations,
and the unemployment rate fell from 7.3 percent to 6.4 percent (Topolnicki
percent of those college graduates who look for employment are finding work
within 6 months, and 75 percent consider their jobs genuine beginnings of a
career ladder (Smith 1994).
to one outplacement firm, job searches for its laid-off midlevel executive
clients averaged 3.8 months in 1993 versus 6 months in 1991 and 1992 (Caminiti
Even though the economy is recovering, recession and restructuring have
permanently changed the way successful job searchers approach the task of
finding employment (Farnham 1993). Many individuals who have been successful in
their job search adjusted the process to accommodate the recent recession and
the continuing restructuring.
THE JOB SEARCH PROCESS
An information-gathering process
that involves both internal and external exploration, the job search can be
adapted to the current context. Internal exploration focuses on an individual's
personal traits whereas external exploration involves obtaining job-related
information from friends, family, employment agencies, and other sources
(Silliker 1993). External exploration, which is composed of formal and informal
methods, has been most affected by the changing economy. Examples of formal
external search methods include responding to advertisements and using public
and private employment services. Informal methods include using family, friends,
and acquaintances as contacts and sources of information (Carson 1989).
Another way of analyzing the job search process is by thinking about the job
market in two broad categories: the open market and the hidden or unpublished
market. The open market consists of employment agencies, temporary firms, and
advertisements. The hidden market consists of those job leads and openings that
must be ferreted out through personal contacts and networking. Although both
markets contain jobs, most jobs are in the hidden or unpublished market that is
accessed primarily through informal strategies (Weinstein 1993). Thus, informal,
external methods take on added importance as strategies for locating jobs.
STRATEGIES FOR NEW COLLEGE GRADUATES
graduates who had positive job search outcomes used many of the following
strategies (Farnham 1993; Martin 1993; Richman 1994; Smith 1994; Vinton 1992;
Williams and Gajalla 1993):
started early. Freshman year is not too early to begin thinking about employment
following graduation. Part of an early start includes participating in
extracurricular activities as a demonstration of leadership. An early start can
demonstrate planning ability.
acquired job experience through internships and cooperative education.
"Internships are becoming more and more important. That's when students learn
the soft skills of working in a corporate environment" (Martin 1993, p. 14). Not
only does work experience stand out, many companies are making full-time offers
only to those graduates who have served internships. For example, General Mills,
which has been offering one-third of its job openings to those college graduates
who served as interns, plans to increase that number to between 40 and 50
percent (Farnham 1993).
of waiting for employers to come to campus, they went directly to them. Small
and medium-sized companies are where most graduates will find work but most do
not have the resources for campus recruiting. Like large companies, these
employers are looking for "team players with strong work records" but they are
less choosy (Smith 1994, p. 60).
made hunting a job a full-time job. They were serious about devoting time and
work to all the steps involved in a successful job search.
made use of all networks and connections. In addition to talking to family,
friends, and acquaintances, they expanded their professional networks by reading
trade magazines, joining professional associations, and attending conferences.
According to Farnham (1993), "Jobs [for new college graduates] are out
there--and good ones. But to get them, students are having to look earlier, work
harder, work smarter, and sometimes venture off the beaten path" (p. 60). Not
all students are heeding this advice. A study of communication majors found
that, although students had the right ideas to support their search during
difficult economic times (e.g., a willingness to accept a lower starting salary
and to relocate), nearly 70 percent of the respondents had not visited their
college career center (Williams and Gajalla 1993).
STRATEGIES FOR DISLOCATED WHITE-COLLAR WORKERS
every $10,000 they earn they will average about the equivalent of 1 month of job
hunting, most laid-off managers or professionals can expect to find a comparable
new position (Topolnicki 1994). White-collar managers and employees who
successfully reentered the job market often used the following strategies
(Caminiti 1994; Topolnicki 1994; Weinstein 1993):
approached their job search as if it were a full-time job, establishing regular
procedures and routines that ensured they would spend adequate time on their job
tap into the hidden or unpublished job market, they made extensive use of their
networks. Rather than concealing their job loss, they made use of all contacts,
talking to anyone who might give them a lead. Many expanded their networks by
joining support groups designed to assist with the job search. "[The] great
thing about networking is that it allows you to find out about opportunities
within a company before they ever surface anywhere else...do you know what a
tremendous edge that gives you?" (Caminiti 1994, p. 10).
also used formal methods such as executive recruiting firms and responding to
advertisements to access the open market. Even though fewer than 10 percent of
job seekers find jobs through want ads, they checked trade publications and put
extra effort into their written replies. A surprising number of displaced
managers and professionals--20 percent--found work through executive recruiting
firms (Topolnicki 1994).
turned to temporary or part-time work. This strategy not only allowed them to
keep up in their fields but it also allowed them to tap into another networking
system and prove themselves with a company. Increasingly, companies are using
temporary positions as a way to "try out" prospective employees.
The following conclusions are based on the
commonalities between contemporary job search strategies for new college
graduates and for laid-off, white-collar workers.
experience pays off. Work experience with a prospective employer through
internships is becoming more critical for college students. Using temporary or
part-time work as an entre to full-time work is also emerging as a strategy for
a job must be thought of as a job. Such a perspective ensures that time and
energy will be devoted to the job search.
is essential. Silliker (1993) recommends that job seekers need to be trained and
encouraged to use their networks, suggesting that early career planning and
career education should include a specific social networking competency.
of information technology is the "wave of the future." Although recommended as a
strategy for both groups (Smith 1994; Topolnicki 1994), it is not yet clear how
widely used it is. Kennedy and Morrow (1994) describe how information technology
is changing the way people look for jobs. With the expansion of the Internet and
other electronic networking services, it is clear that in the future successful
job seekers will make full use of these resources.
Caminiti, S. "What Happens to Laid-Off
Managers." FORTUNE 129, no. 12 (June 13, 1994): 68-70, 72 ff.
Carson, E. "Social Networks in the Labour Market--The Sociology of Job
Search." AUSTRALIAN BULLETIN OF LABOUR 15, no. 4 (September 1989): 287-323.
Church, G. J. "Jobs in an Age of Insecurity." TIME 142, no. 22 (November 22,
Farnham, A. "Out of College, What's Next?" FORTUNE 128, no. 1 (July 12,
Gardner, J. M. "The 1990-91 Recession: How Bad Was the Labor Market?" MONTHLY
LABOR REVIEW 117, no. 6 (June 1994): 3-11.
Kennedy, J. L., and Morrow, T. J. ELECTRONIC JOB SEARCH REVOLUTION. New York:
Martin, J. "Interns Have Edge on Jobs." FORTUNE 127, no. 10 (May 17, 1993):
Richman, L. S. "How to Get Ahead in America." FORTUNE 129, no. 10 (May 16,
1994): 46-50, 54.
Silliker, S. A. "The Role of Social Contacts in the Successful Job Search."
JOURNAL OF EMPLOYMENT COUNSELING 30, no. 1 (March 1993): 25-34.
Smith, L. "Landing that First Real Job." FORTUNE 129, no. 10 (May 16, 1994):
Topolnicki, D. M. "Get on the New Fast Track." MONEY 22, no. 12 (December
Topolnicki, D. M. "Go from Pink Slip to Paycheck." MONEY 23, no. 3 (March
Vinton, D. "Helping Students Find Time for the Job Search." JOURNAL OF CAREER
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT 52, no. 3 (March 1992): 71-74.
Weinstein, B. RESUMES DON'T GET JOBS: THE REALITIES AND MYTHS OF JOB HUNTING.
New York: McGraw-Hill, 1993.
Williams, S. L., and Gajalla, R. "Enter at Your Own Risk: Communications
Majors Student Attitudes and Assessments about the 'Real World' and Their
Readiness for It." Paper presented at the Joint Southern Speech Communication
Association and Central States Communication Association Annual Convention,
Lexington, KY, April 1993. (ED 361 815)