Linking Law-Related Education to Reducing Violence
by and against Youth. ERIC Digest.
by Pereira, Carolyn
The American Psychological Association (1993, 1) defines violence as
"immediate or chronic situations that result in injury to the psychological,
social, or physical well being of individuals or groups." Violence by and
against youth has increased over the last two decades cutting across racial
and socio-economic lines. Assaults are on the increase. Verbal abuse is
more widespread. A lack of civility in relationships at school is a common
complaint of educators across the country. Reports of violence fill the
media daily. Most violence has traditionally occurred between people who
know each other. Acts of random violence, however, appear to be on the
increase. Motivating factors range from arguments that get out of hand
to gang-related incidents. In a recent survey conducted by the National
School Boards Association, school superintendents from urban, suburban,
and rural districts ranked family problems and violence in the media as
the most significant factors associated with an increase in violence (Elliott
WHAT PERSONAL QUALITIES ARE ASSOCIATED WITH REDUCTION OF VIOLENCE?
Children are less likely to become violent if they develop particular
skills, attitudes, and patterns of behavior.
*Problem-solving and reasoning skills: Children who think that there
are only two ways to solve problems--fight or give-up--are more likely
to become either perpetrators or victims of violence. Children's ability
to reason well can give them a wider variety of options than just fighting
or running. Children who are more proficient at generating and evaluating
options in academic and social settings are less likely to choose violent
ways of solving conflicts.
*Social capacities: These skills, attitudes, and dispositions include
development of empathy, effective communication, humor, and attachment
to positive, non-violent individuals or groups. Understanding another person's
point of view and having concern for other persons can help students generate
a wider variety of options--some of which may be mutually acceptable. Students
must be able both to listen with understanding and to be understood. The
ability to laugh and create moments where others, too, feel more light-hearted
can often become one of the most successful options to reducing violent
responses. Humor can also enable someone not to immediately take things
too personally. The ability to be a friend and have friends can create
a stronger desire to find non-violent ways of solving conflicts.
*A productive sense of purpose, independence, and power: Children who
are more likely to turn to violence have no hope in the future. Conversely,
children who believe they can control their lives and want to direct their
lives in positive and productive ways are more likely to seek non-violent
means to resolve conflict.
WHAT CAN TEACHERS AND PARENTS DO TO FOSTER NON-VIOLENT CONFLICT RESOLUTION?
Teachers and parents can act positively to reduce violent behavior among
*Expect children to achieve high standards: If teachers, family, and
others expect children to do their best both academically and socially,
children, more often than not, rise to the challenge. If key people in
the child's environment give clear and consistent signals that violence
is not the norm, children will be more likely to develop non-violent patterns
*Provide meaningful opportunities for participation: In order to develop
the skills and predispositions for resolving conflict peaceably, children
need to be given opportunities to practice these techniques. Opportunities
need to be based on experiences which relate to their own lives and are
viewed as important, not just busy work.
*Recognize positive accomplishments: Children need to know when they
are on the "right" track. Feedback is important. Recognition, however,
needs to fit the accomplishment. Too much or too little praise, or rewards
which have little connection to the task, can be distracting.
*Provide positive role models for children: All children need at least
one adult whom they recognize as caring about them. Knowing that respected
adults support non-violence, and value being a member of groups that solve
problems non-violently, further encourage children to seek non-violent
solutions in conflict situations.
HOW CAN LRE ADDRESS THE PROBLEMS OF VIOLENCE BY AND AGAINST YOUTH?
Law-related education (LRE) is designed to help young people develop
into knowledgeable, skilled, and caring citizens. Young people with these
qualities, who are given productive, responsible roles, are less likely
to be involved in undesirable behavior, including violence. The outcome
of a model LRE program is a class of students ready to assume their roles
as constructive participants in our pluralistic democracy, not just problem-free
young people. Law-related education can create a learning environment to
nurture the skills, attitudes, and patterns of responsible behavior associated
with the reduction of violence.
Law-related education helps children develop problem-solving and reasoning
skills through challenging content and the methods used to study that content.
The curriculum provides rich opportunities for students to develop these
skills by analyzing Supreme Court cases, playing roles of police officers
on the job, and participating in mock trials, mediations, and legislative
hearings. The complex questions generated in each of these contexts encourage
a variety of answers, which involve careful examination and projection
of possible consequences of the decisions.
Social skills developed through interactions with outside resource persons,
as well as with other students through cooperative learning activities,
can create positive attachments to prosocial individuals and groups.
LRE helps children develop a productive sense of purpose, independence,
and power through participatory teaching strategies that demonstrate how
people can and should make a difference in improving the system of justice.
Studying key Supreme Court cases, such as Gideon v. Wainwright and Brown
v. Board of Education, provides students with concrete examples of how
people can work within the legal system to improve it.
Law-related education involves high expectations for all students, not
just the academically gifted, and requires the use of complex skills. For
example, successfully negotiating a dispute requires a high level of interpersonal
and reasoning skills. In addition, LRE conveys a message that this country
is based on the rule of law, which provides a variety of ways to resolve
conflict without violence.
LRE provides opportunities for meaningful participation. Questions of
public policy, such as "Should curfews be imposed on young people in order
to curb crime?", offer opportunities for students to research, discuss,
and act on important issues that affect them directly.
Recognition of positive accomplishments is part of law-related education.
Further, LRE involves supportive adults or outside resource persons, such
as caring police officers, judges, and attorneys, who are involved in the
daily administration of justice. They are available to talk with young
people, to acknowledge concerns young people have about the imperfections
of the legal system, and to demonstrate how to work constructively within
Careful research needs to be done on the relationship between LRE and
violence prevention. However, the many links that LRE has to youth development
and the risk factors related to violence provide optimism about LRE's potential
as a part of a systematic, collaborative, and comprehensive violence reduction
and youth development program.
REFERENCES AND ERIC RESOURCES
The following list of resources includes references used to prepare
this Digest. The items followed by an ED number are available in microfiche
and/or paper copies from the ERIC Document Reproduction Services (EDRS).
For information about prices, contact EDRS, 7420 Fullerton Road, Suite
110, Springfield, Virginia 22153-2842; telephone numbers are 703/440-1440
and 800/443-3742. Entries followed by an EJ number, annotated monthly in
CURRENT INDEX TO JOURNALS IN EDUCATION (CIJE), are not available through
EDRS. They can be located in the journal section of most larger libraries
by using the bibliographic information provided, requested through Interlibrary
Loan, or ordered from the UMI reprint service.
American Psychological Association. VIOLENCE AND YOUTH: PSYCHOLOGY'S
RESPONSE. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 1993.
Curcio, Joan, and Patricia First. VIOLENCE IN THE SCHOOLS: HOW TO PROACTIVELY
PREVENT AND DEFUSE IT. Newbury Park, CA: Corwin Press, 1993. ED 358 548.
Elliott, Delbert S. YOUTH VIOLENCE: AN OVERVIEW. Boulder, CO: The Center
for the Study and Prevention of Violence, 1994.
Emery, Kathleen J. POSITION STATEMENT ON YOUTH VIOLENCE PREVENTION AND
RECOMMENDED ACTIONS. Dayton, OH: New Futures for Dayton Area Youth, Inc.,
1993. ED 357 091.
Felgar, Michelle A. "Gangs and Youth Violence." JOURNAL OF EMOTIONAL
AND BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS 1 (Spring 1992): 9-12. EJ 480 807.
Fenley, Mary Ann, and others. THE PREVENTION OF YOUTH VIOLENCE: A FRAMEWORK
FOR COMMUNITY ACTION. Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
1993. ED 360 610.
Guerra, Nancy, and Patrick Tolin. WHAT WORKS IN REDUCING ADOLESCENT
VIOLENCE. Chicago, IL: University of Illinois at Chicago, 1994.
Jenkins, Esther J., and Carl C. Bell. "Adolescent Violence: Can It Be
Curbed?" ADOLESCENT MEDICINE: STATE OF THE ART REVIEWS 3 (February 1992):
McBee, Robin Haskell. "Law-Related Education and Violence Prevention."
SCHOOL SAFETY (Spring 1995): 24-28.
Mulhern, Sean, and others. PREVENTING YOUTH VIOLENCE AND AGGRESSION
AND PROMOTING SAFETY IN SCHOOLS. Madison, WI: Wisconsin State Department
of Public Instruction, 1994. ED 368 989.
Reno, Janet. "The Whole Child Approach to Crime." SPECTRUM: THE JOURNAL
OF STATE GOVERNMENT 66 (Summer 1993): 31-36. EJ 473 976.
Wright, Norma. FROM RISK TO RESILIENCY: THE ROLE OF LAW-RELATED EDUCATION.
Calabasas, CA: Center for Civic Education, 1994. ED 377 123.
YOUTH VIOLENCE. Washington, DC: Congress of the U.S., Senate Committee
on the Judiciary, 1994. ED 368 830.