ERIC Identifier: ED393786
Publication Date: 1996-02-00
Author: Hume, Susan E.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse for
Social Studies/Social Science Education Bloomington IN.
Using Literature To Teach Geography in High Schools. ERIC
Traditionally, the high school curriculum has been rigidly compartmentalized.
Yet, linkages between disciplines in the curriculum increasingly are being made,
such as the connections of English to U.S. History courses in many high schools.
Another connection may be English with World Geography courses. Students of
every ability level could benefit from exploring the interrelationship between
these two disciplines.
In this ERIC Digest, the term literature refers to novels, short stories,
poetry, plays, and folk tales. It consists of narrative as opposed to expository
forms of writing that are found in traditional textbooks, reference books, and
news articles. By no means, however, should literature be the sole tool used to
teach geography or other subjects of the social studies. Rather, each form of
narrative and expository writing has its place in the social studies curriculum.
WHY USE LITERATURE TO TEACH GEOGRAPHY?
three main reasons for using a literature-based approach to teach geography.
1. There is a natural link between geography and literature. Author and
teacher Kenneth Mitchell eloquently describes this link: "Geography has a
profound influence in shaping any society....[L]iterature, like all art, is
ultimately a reflection and illustration of the landscape that produced it"
(Mallory & Simpson-Housley 1986, 23).
How does this natural link apply to the classroom? Virtually every story has
a setting that can be expressed in geographical terms. With a literature-based
approach to geography, each discipline can enrich and reinforce learning in the
other. Students also can begin to see that both geography and literature have
relevance outside the classroom.
2. The study of literature improves comprehension of geography. Research has
shown that geographic awareness among students is influenced more by travel
experience than by any other factor (Bein 1990). Obviously, it is impossible to
take every student on a tour of the world. The challenge is to create a learning
environment that comes closest to being in a place. Literature comes nearer to
achieving this goal than most other resources. Even audio-visual materials
cannot explicitly convey the smells, tastes, and other sensations of a place as
can a well-written piece of literature.
Several advocates of a literature-based approach to geography argue that
students are more likely to understand geographical concepts if they have real
people and situations to use as models (Friend & Thompson 1986, McGowan
& Guzzetti 1991, Silverman 1981). Textbooks typically bombard the reader
with densely packed concepts and superficial explanations (Ornstein 1992, 168).
Literature, by contrast, allows students to focus and reflect upon a few
concepts at a time (McGowan & Guzzetti 1991, 17).
In 1984, the Joint Committee on Geographic Education developed the five
themes of geography: location, place, human/environmental interaction, movement,
and regions. At least one of the five themes can be found in every piece of
literature (Fitzhugh 1992, 5).
3. A literature-based approach to geography improves reading comprehension.
In a typical high school classroom, students' reading abilities can range from a
fourth- or fifth-grade level to the equivalent of a college junior. The use of a
single textbook is inappropriate for the reading levels of many, if not most,
students. Students who read materials other than textbooks in their classes
demonstrate a broader vocabulary and greater reading comprehension than if they
use textbooks alone (Smith, Monson, & Dobson 1992, 370). Further, narrative
is usually more intriguing and enjoyable to read than expository forms of
writing. A piece of literature is more likely than a textbook to capture
students' interests and imaginations. Students taught with a literature-based
approach have better attitudes toward reading (Smith, Monson, & Dobson 1992,
CHOOSING APPROPRIATE PIECES OF LITERATURE.
needs to develop his or her own guidelines or criteria for choosing appropriate
literature to use in a geography classroom. Knowing the special needs of one's
students and clearly defining course objectives are both important factors. For
instance, Friend and Thompson consider the work's literary quality, geographical
value, and character appeal for their students (1986). McGowan and Guzzetti add
that they look for materials which avoid stereotypical and inaccurate
information (1991, 18). Palmer and Smith have developed a geo-literature model
that contains a six-step strategy for choosing and using literature to
understand the National Geography Standards (1995, 2).
At least one additional factor should be considered when choosing a piece of
literature: Was it written by a person who lives in that place or region? Many
American authors, especially of books for young readers, write about places in
the world that they may have briefly visited, or perhaps they have never gone to
these places. These books may be well written and accurate. Yet, what better way
to teach students about a place than through the voice of someone who lives
there? Just as students profit from exposure to a variety of reading materials,
they can also benefit from a variety of perspectives (Ornstein 1992, 68). Books
written by authors from around the world are readily available. However, one
should be careful never to sacrifice literary quality and content relevance in
the interest of finding an indigenous author.
SUGGESTIONS FOR USING "THE GRAPES OF WRATH" TO TEACH GEOGRAPHY
The writings of John Steinbeck have traditionally been a staple
of high school English departments. His work has valuable applications for the
high school geography classroom as well. Whether used in its entirety or through
excerpts, THE GRAPES OF WRATH provides an excellent vehicle with which to teach
many of the 1994 National Geography Standards. With these standards in mind, the
following is a small sample of the questions that students can explore as they
read the novel.
* What images come to mind upon hearing the words "Oklahoma" and
"California?" What did these words mean to Americans in the 1930s?
* What physical and human characteristics define eastern Oklahoma and
California's Central Valley? What role has irrigation played in shaping the
landscape and economic development of the Central Valley?
* What factors contributed to the transition from small family farms to large
commercial farms in both Oklahoma and California? What human and environmental
forces drove the Joads and other families from their land in Oklahoma, and what
drew them to California?
* In the 1930s, what attitudes did people in western states have toward the
arrival of migrant workers? Can parallels be drawn between those attitudes and
the attitudes toward migrants today?
* How have the features and functions of Highway 66 changed from the
migration of farm families to southern California in the 1930s, to the 1940s
when Nat King Cole sang his famous song about ROUTE 66, to the 1960s when the
interstate system was established, and to the present day when the once-famous
highway has virtually disappeared?
* Through which towns, cities, and states did Highway 66 pass? When people
drive from Chicago to Los Angeles today, which interstate highways do they take?
Which towns on Highway 66 were bypassed with the construction of the interstate
system? How were those places affected economically and socially?
Steinbeck describes the land and its people in such vivid detail that the
study of geography becomes a natural extension of the literature. Through the
GRAPES OF WRATH, geography takes on new relevance as well as aesthetic beauty.
REFERENCES AND ERIC RESOURCES
The following list includes
references used to prepare this Digest. The items followed by an ED number are
available in microfiche and/or paper copies from the ERIC Document Reproduction
Service (EDRS). For information about prices, contact EDRS, 7420 Fullerton Road,
Suite 110, Springfield, Virginia, 22153-2852; telephone numbers are (703)
440-1400 and (800) 443-3742. Entries followed by an EJ number, announced monthly
in the CURRENT INDEX TO JOURNALS IN EDUCATION (CIJE), are not available through
EDRS. However, they can be located in the journal section of most larger
libraries by using the bibliographic information provided, requested through
Interlibrary Loan, or ordered from the UMI reprint service.
Bednarz, Sarah Witham, and others. GEOGRAPHY FOR LIFE: NATIONAL GEOGRAPHY
STANDARDS, 1994. Washington, DC: National Geographic Society, 1994. ED 375 073.
Bein, Frederick L. "Baseline Geography Competency Test: Administered in
Indiana Universities." JOURNAL OF GEOGRAPHY 89 (November/December 1990):
260-265. EJ 427 716.
Davis, John C., III, and Jesse Palmer. "A Strategy for Using Children's
Literature to Extend the Social Studies Curriculum." THE SOCIAL STUDIES 83
(May/June 1992): 125-128. EJ 458 404.
Fitzhugh, William P. GEOGRAPHY AND LITERATURE: THE LITERACY CONNECTION. Paper
presented at the Annual Conference of the State of Maryland International
Reading Association Council, Towson, Maryland, March 1992. ED 359 109.
Friend, A. J., and K. Thompson. A WORLD OF FICTION: GLOBAL INSIGHTS IN
FICTIONAL LITERATURE. A project derived from the Global Studies Institute,
Sturbridge, Massachusetts, July 1986. ED 289 787.
Guzzetti, Barbara J., Barbara J. Kowalinski, and Tom McGowan. "Using a
Literature-based Approach to Teaching Social Studies." JOURNAL OF READING 36
(October 1992): 114-122. EJ 451 279.
Joint Committee on Geographic Education. GUIDELINES FOR GEOGRAPHIC EDUCATION: ELEMENTARY AND SECONDARY SCHOOLS. Macomb, IL: National Council for Geographic Education, 1984.ED 252 453.
Mallory, W. E., and P. Simpson-Housley. GEOGRAPHY AND LITERATURE: A MEETING
OF THE DISCIPLINES. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, 1986.
McGowan, Tom, and Barbara Guzzetti. "Promoting Social Studies Understanding
Through Literature-based Instruction." THE SOCIAL STUDIES 82 (January/February
1991): 16-21. EJ 427 757.
Ornstein, Allan C. "The Textbook Curriculum." EDUCATIONAL HORIZONS 70 (Summer
1992): 167-169. EJ 453 995.
Palmer, Jesse, and Ben A. Smith. GEO-LITERATURE: USINGCHILDREN'S LITERATURE TO HELP UNDERSTAND THE NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC STANDARDS. Paper presented at the 75th AnnualMeeting of the National Council for the Social Studies, Chicago, Illinois, November 12, 1995.
Silverman, S. E. THE USE OF FICTIONAL LITERATURE IN TEACHING CONCEPTS OF
CULTURAL GEOGRAPHY. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National
Council for Geographic Education, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, October 29, 1981. ED
Smith, John A., Jay A. Monson, and Dorothy Dobson. "A Case Study on
Integrating History and Reading Instruction Through Literature." SOCIAL
EDUCATION 56 (November/December 1992): 370-374. EJ 463 238.