ERIC Identifier: ED407575
Publication Date: 1997-00-00
Author: Brown, Bettina Lankard
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse
on Adult Career and Vocational Education Columbus OH.
Adding International Perspectives to Vocational Education. ERIC
Digest No. 183.
International work opportunities are increasing as the borders of the U.S.
economy expand to embrace international markets. Future workers will need to
develop global awareness and an understanding of competitive, cultural, and
economic factors that influence ways of doing business in order to work in the
international arena. This Digest examines the instructional approaches and
strategies used in vocational education to prepare students to work in a global
The Industrial Age expanded the vision of U.S. workers beyond their local
communities to the country's national borders. The current Information Age moves
the focus to global boundaries. To meet the competitive challenges of a global
economy, businesses are looking for workers who have cross-cultural knowledge;
intercultural communication skills, and an awareness of the political,
geographical, and technological conditions that influence work in other
countries (Hart et al. 1994; Philpott 1994). In a survey to elicit chief
executive officers' expectations of collegiate international business
preparation, "84% of the chief executive officers indicated that 'global
awareness' is a key ingredient of international business expertise" (Hart et al.
1994, p. 104).
The preparation of individuals for work in a global economy is a challenge to
educational institutions. Considering the limited international experience of
most students, the challenge is formidable. Smith and Steward (1995) contrast
the cross-cultural education experiences of U.S. students to those of students
from other countries. They note that "currently there are 240,000 Asians
studying in the U.S. and less than 5,000 U.S. students studying in Asia" (p.
25). In a society characterized by cultural diversity, limited experience with
people from other cultures places Americans at a disadvantage in achieving
international understanding and social awareness. How can vocational education,
the educational program area that is specifically designed to prepare students
for work, infuse international concepts into vocational education programs so
that the youth of today are prepared for the global workplace? Ostheimer (1995)
offers several suggestions:
1. Promote global awareness.
2. Internationalize the curriculum.
3. Adopt instructional practices that incorporate international dimensions.
4. Provide resources that address international/global dimensions of
5. Provide faculty development programs in international business.
With the growth of multinational
corporations and increased trade among nations, workers need to understand
global conditions, development, and trends. Such issues as population growth,
wealth distribution, environmental concerns, diseases, and political and social
problems as well as cultural issues such as religious beliefs, customs, and
family structure have implications for a country's business activity and
practices. The study of such issues will enhance students' abilities to engage
in job-related problem solving and decision making in ways that reflect
knowledge of and respect for other cultures (McLaughlin 1996).
Classroom study, even when it includes international content, cannot provide
the extent of global awareness that one can achieve through international
experiences. In a study of chief executive officers, 53.8% of the respondents
stressed the importance of foreign exchange and internship programs in preparing
workers for international business positions. Experience, travel, and overseas
assignments were also listed as important considerations (Hart et al. 1994).
The literature describes a number
of examples vocational educators can draw upon as guides to internationalizing
the curriculum. Many of them involve students in studying and comparing U.S.
systems with those of other countries, e.g., agriculture, transportation, and
family living. A multicultural vocational education program in Omaha, Nebraska,
for example, incorporates lesson plans dealing with such topics as "housing
around the world, regional cuisines, world hunger, clothing in other cultures,
and birth customs of different cultures" (Dovel 1991, p. 24). Ball State
University offered seminars on the study of transportation in other countries.
The seminars "caused students to understand the development of foreign
transportation systems as well as examine the peoples' relationship with those
systems. The information about each culture was supplemented with pictures of
the people, their homes and cities" (McLaughlin 1996, p. 18).
Ibezim and McCracken (1994) stress the importance of internationalizing the
curriculum, with specific reference to agricultural education: "It has become
clear that for a student to be considered educated in agriculture, he or she
must be cognizant of the interrelationships of various agricultural systems and
the governments, cultures, and societies in which they function. It is no longer
sufficient to know how to produce food and fiber" (p. 10). In a study of the
internationalization of a secondary-level agricultural program--a study that
involved agricultural teachers in 12 states of the North Central Region--"the
most integrated dimensions were origin of crops, agricultural technology,
agricultural trade, geographical factors, economic factors, and political
factors" (p. 46).
communication is one way to help students overcome the parochialism that comes
from cultural isolation in that it affords a means of connecting students of
different nationalities and backgrounds. Smith and Steward (1995) offer the
following suggestions for upgrading communication curricula to take students
beyond awareness of other cultures to competence in intercultural communication
1. Provide a cognitive instructional framework from which students can
develop communication strategies related to elements of (1) oral and written
intercultural communication, including negotiations; (2) techniques to overcome
language barriers, both oral and written; and (3) advantages and disadvantages
of using interpreters.
2. Lead students to examine the emotional (or affective) aspects of
intercultural communication, e.g., sensitivity to intercultural differences and
different value systems, the impact of culture on personal attitudes, behaviors,
and communication; and the distinction between true and false perceptions in
reaching a true understanding of a foreign culture's communication process.
3. Provide experiences through which students can engage in real-life
application of the skills they learn. For example, students should be given
opportunities to write letters, memoranda, and reports for intercultural
audiences; make presentations using interpreters; use telecommunications
technology; engage in simulated intercultural negotiation experiences; and so
The World Wide Web offers another means of broadening students' global
horizons. Recent publications on using the Internet for international exposure
include those by Molloy (1996), Frazier et al. (1995), and Pachnowski (1996).
Molloy (1996) provides a directory of products, services, and other resources
pertaining to Latin America that are available on Internet. Frazier et al.
(1995) offer guides to becoming informed world citizens and locating maps.
Pachnowski (1996) describes the vast amount of data available through Internet
and provides an extensive list of educational resources, including American
Educational Research Association and International Exchange Classroom
Connections mailing lists, the World Wide Web, and addresses for Usenet news
groups and gophers.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS PROGRAMS
One of the insights of the
study by Hart et al. (1994) is the perception of business executives that
increased corporate input is necessary for international business program
development. The first-hand knowledge and experiences of corporate
representatives working in firms that conduct international business offer a
current and practical basis for upgrading curricula. Vocational education
instructors can expand their repertoire of resources by sharing curriculum
materials and designs with instructors around the world. Other strategies and
activities may be uncovered by reviewing the experiences of youth and adult
leadership organizations, such as Future Farmers of America (Martin 1993).
Educational resources can also be located in the ERIC database and on the World
For postsecondary faculty, community and technical colleges could form an
international faculty committee to review curriculum, integrate international
components, acquire materials, and attend seminars (Delaney 1995). Wismer (1994)
recommends that colleges (1) establish a cross-functional task force to develop
a comprehensive plan for international education and training; (2) form
alliances with government, business, and industry to develop competencies for
students and business employees, which also strengthen local economic
development; and (3) establish advisory boards from local business and industry
to provide valuable input into training programs. Tech prep programs offer
another strategy for infusing international content into vocational programs.
Sutliff (1996), who visited London to share tech prep tips, suggests broadening
the scope of tech prep to focus on preparing a world-class work force for global
Faculty development is crucial to the
implementation of programs that have an international component. Ibezim and
McCracken (1994) suggest that "agricultural teachers who exhibit higher degrees
of cultural awareness would be more likely to internationalize their
agricultural instruction" (p. 48). This is not surprising as teachers themselves
need a base of knowledge and experience in international practices before they
can impart their knowledge to students. Because many teachers have had no
international education themselves, opportunities like staff development
workshops and seminars, externships in other countries, study tours, continuing
education courses in international business, and participation in business
associations and organizations that promote international education would add
valuable insight into the issues they should be addressing in their instruction
and classroom curriculum.
The global workplace is a reality. Global
competition as well as the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) have stimulated the growth of
multinational corporations as well as increased trade among nations (McLaughlin
1996, p. 14). The U.S. population will continue to reflect cultural diversity,
which requires an awareness, understanding, and joining of people from diverse
backgrounds who can work together to accomplish family, community, and economic
goals. Vocational education can make a major contribution by adding
international perspectives to its vocational education programs.
Ahmed, Z. V. and Krohn, F. B. "The Symbiosis of
Liberal Arts and International Business." JOURNAL OF EDUCATION FOR BUSINESS 69,
no. 4 (March-April 1994): 199-203.
Delaney, E. INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS COURSES AND PROGRAMS AT DAYTONA BEACH
COMMUNITY COLLEGE. Daytona Beach, FL: Daytona Beach Community College, 1995. (ED
Dovel, J. "Lessons in Respect. Omaha's Vocational Courses Include Multi
Cultural Perspectives." VOCATIONAL EDUCATION JOURNAL 66, no. 8
(November-December 1991): 24-25.
Frazier, D. et al. INTERNET FOR KIDS. Alameda, CA: SYBEX Inc., 1995. (ED 395
Hart, S. A. et al. "A Survey of Corporate Executives' Perceptions of
Collegiate International Business Preparation." DELTA PI EPSILON JOURNAL 36, no.
2 (Spring 1994): 96-109.
Ibezim, D. O., and McCracken, J. D. "Factors Associated with
Internationalization of Secondary Level Agricultural Education Programs."
JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL EDUCATION 35, no. 3 (1994): 44-49.
Martin, R. A. "Internationalizing Agricultural Education--A Rationale."
AGRICULTURAL EDUCATION MAGAZINE 65, no. 10 (April 1993): 21-22.
McLaughlin, C. H. "Implications of Global Change: Technology Education's
Role." TECHNOLOGY TEACHER 55, no. 5 (February 1996): 14-18.
Molloy, M., comp. INTERNET RESOURCES FOR LATIN AMERICA. Version 3.2. at
gopher://lib.nmsu.edu:70/00/.subjects/.border/.lagall, April 1997. (ED 399 098)
Ostheimer, S. "Internationalize Yourself and Your Classes, School, and
Community." BUSINESS EDUCATION FORUM 49, no. 3 (February 1995): 44-47.
Pachnowski, L. "The Internet: A Powerful Resource for Educators." Paper
presented at the Annual Meeting of the Eastern Educational Research Association,
Boston, MA, February 1996. (ED 393 447)
Philpott, M. "Business Beyond Our Borders: An Integrated Approach." BUSINESS
EDUCATION FORUM 48, no. 3 (February 1994): 21-25.
Smith, M. O., and Steward, J. F. "Communication for a Global Economy."
BUSINESS EDUCATION FORUM 49, no. 4 (April 1995): 25-28.
Sutliff, L. "The English Translation." VOCATIONAL EDUCATION JOURNAL 71, no. 4
(April 1996): 38-39, 57.
Wismer, J. N. "Training for Trade: Role of American Community Colleges."
Paper presented at a conference of the American Council on International and
Intercultural Education, Colorado Springs, CO, April 21, 1994. (ED 371 789)