Teaching Young Gifted Children in the Regular
Classroom. ERIC Digest.
by Smutny, Joan Franklin
Recognizing and nurturing giftedness in young children presents an important
challenge to educators. Schools need to respond to their educational needs
before their abilities diminish or become less recognizable to those who
can do something about them.
Giftedness in young children refers primarily to "precocity," a rapid
rate of development in one or more realms. To some people, giftedness is
purely academic and means, for example, that a child earns all A's on report
cards. That child may be gifted, along with the children who, at age 3,
can count to 100 or read a book, or pick out a tune on the piano.
But giftedness is more than developing skills faster or going through
the developmental milestones earlier. Young gifted children are intensely
curious, produce a constant stream of questions, learn quickly and remember
easily, and think about the world differently than their age-mates. Their
intense curiosity may get them into trouble, particularly when they try
to figure out how something works. They may have a super-high energy level
and yet be highly sensitive and perfectionists. Young gifted children are
at risk for boredom, frustration, and depression. Recognizing giftedness
is important because to persist, giftedness needs nurturing.
Schools have often shied away from early intervention precisely because
of the challenge of identification, and because initial assessments are
often minimal estimations of a child's actual talent. The most effective
way to recognize and identify giftedness is to use a variety of approaches
over an extended period of time. Physical, social, and cognitive development
is rapid and variable in young children. Cognitive and motor skills come
suddenly: one moment the skill is not observable, then it suddenly appears.
For this reason, testing may work at one time and not at another. A more
complete picture of giftedness in young gifted children would involve observations
of behavior and verbal ability in different classroom settings, anecdotal
information from parents, and child products (art work, diagrams, inventions,
Lego buildings, stories-written or told).
Gifted Behaviors. One way to begin finding gifted children is to focus
on a range of behaviors that occur in the daily conversations, activities,
and responses to learning opportunities in and around the classroom. Here
is a list of characteristics common in gifted four-, five-, and six-year
* express curiosity about many things
* ask thoughtful questions
* have extensive vocabularies and use complex sentence structure
* are able to express themselves well
* solve problems in unique ways
* have good memories
* exhibit unusual talent in art, music, or creative dramatics
* exhibit especially original imaginations
* use previously learned things in new contexts
* are unusually able to order things in logical sequence
* discuss and elaborate on ideas
* are fast learners
* desire to work independently and take initiative
* exhibit wit and humor
* have sustained attention spans and are willing to persist on challenging
* are very observant
* show talent in making up stories and telling them
* are interested in reading.
Consulting with Parents. Since about 80% of the parent population can
identify their children's giftedness by ages four or five, a short cut
to finding these students is to consult with parents. They have spent hours
every day with their children over a consecutive number of years, observing
them closely and interacting with them in a variety of contexts. In most
cases, this makes them the most realistic predictors of their children's
abilities and needs. Teachers can begin to tap this resource by composing
a short letter at the beginning of the year introducing themselves, describing
the goals for the year, and asking specific questions about the children's
strengths, learning styles, and interests. Later, they can develop a system
for sharing information and insights as the year progresses.
Portfolios. Portfolios present another option for a talent search in
the classroom. A portfolio is a collection of products (e.g., assignments,
paintings, drawings, stories, observations) from school, home, or a community
center. It is a repository of what a child has done or can do. Categories
of achievement and ability could include any of the following: use of language;
level of questioning; problem-solving strategies; depth of information;
breadth of information; creativity; focus on or absorption in a task; profound
interest in existential and spiritual questions; self-evaluation; preference
for complexity or novelty; ability to synthesize, interpret, and imagine.
Portfolios provide authentic assessment. Conducted over an extended period
of time, such evidence is valuable in determining instructional plans,
especially for children in kindergarten to third grade. Both parents and
teachers may use portfolios to identify talent and document its development
GENERAL PRINCIPLES FOR TEACHING YOUNG GIFTED CHILDREN
Many schools today have chosen to serve their gifted student population
by enabling teachers to provide educational alternatives for them within
the existing curriculum and in the regular classroom. There are a number
of practical strategies teachers can employ to give young gifted students
the challenge and stimulation they need without overburdening themselves
with a great deal of extra work.
Create a Learning Environment. One of the first steps to consider when
meeting the needs of young gifted students is the classroom environment.
The classroom needs to be a place where all children can easily engage
in activities and projects at their own level and pace. Here are some suggestions
for designing a child-friendly classroom:
* create a room that invites inquiry (pictures, books, areas for music,
art, and a variety of materials);
* use thematic instruction to connect content areas;
* make a wide range of materials available;
* arrange for activity centers for self-initiated projects;
* have flexible seating arrangements;
* offer attractive, lesson-related activity options for students who
finish work early;
* vary the atmosphere of the room through music as well as opportunities
for creative movement, mime, dance, singing.
Developing learning centers can support creative learning in the classroom
environment. A linguistic center, for example, could have a variety of
books, dictionaries, magazines, storybook character puppets, magnetic letters
with boards, crossword puzzles, alphabet games, and computer software for
word processing and story writing.
Allow for Flexible Grouping. Group work is common in preschool through
the primary grades. For gifted students, cluster groups, where four or
five gifted children work together, provide the most productive situation
for learning. Grouping young children should always enhance the strengths
students have, and the kinds of groups formed (structured, open, creative,
divergent, content-based, etc.) should emerge from learning goals established
for each classroom activity. Here are some guidelines for organizing small
Provide variety. Offer opportunities for children to work with a variety
of students grouped differently (interests, complexity level of assignments,
Offer choices. Whenever possible, allow children to choose group mates
and topics and assist in designing projects and their format.
Create ground rules. Discuss ground rules with children. Rules for discussion
may include: if you can't agree on what to do, try more than one idea;
take turns sharing ideas; listen to others in your group; make your best
effort; help each other; if you don't understand or agree, talk about it
with your group; get the teacher's help if you need it.
Evaluate students individually. At the conclusion of group work, it
is important to evaluate them individually. Evaluations (mastery tests,
portfolios, checklists, oral responses, drawings, written compositions,
etc.) should focus on individual learning rather than on how students contributed
to the group.
Compact the curriculum. A proven strategy for serving young gifted children
in the regular classroom is to compact--a process of compressing the essentials
so that they can advance beyond the material they have already mastered.
Most teachers create a system of testing and observation to determine the
children's level of mastery. There are a couple of options for compacting.
One is to allow gifted children to choose activities (unrelated to material
covered in class) that particularly interest them. The other is to design
an activity related to the current lesson that challenges their talents.
In order for this practice to work in the long run, the teacher will need
to design some kind of learning contract (signed by both the child and
teacher) that stipulates the activities or projects chosen, the conditions
for their completion, and the outcomes. The teacher can then help them
locate resources both in learning centers and the library.
Incorporate creative thinking. Another way to serve young gifted children
in the regular classroom is to incorporate creative thinking and activities
into daily lessons--a strategy that benefits the other students as well.
Young children particularly enjoy "what if" questions to stimulate new
and alternative ways of exploring a subject or theme. A study of the rainforest,
for example, might allow a child with an interest in lizards to become
a lizard for a day. "What if you really were a chameleon living in the
rainforest? What would you enjoy most about being one? Why?" Activities
could include gathering new facts about that animal for the purpose of
a mimed story, a self-portrait (which the child then explains afterwards),
or written (or dictated) story. Teachers can support these activities by
asking questions and suggesting different media and resources for their
Brainstorming with gifted children on what kinds of projects they could
do may also generate ideas teachers may never have thought of on their
own. The point of the brainstorming is to teach children at an early age
to think of the different things they can do with the information they
have learned. What would they like to do with it? What else could they
find out? How would they like to express what they know? Activities could
range (depending on the age and ability of the student) from map-making
to naturalist studies of animal life, dramatic enactment's, creative movement,
art projects, and science experiments. This is where teachers' understanding
of their students' unique strengths becomes vital in providing appropriate
learning activities. A kindergarten class just beginning to explore numbers
may be very dull to an artistically gifted child who already knows how
to count to 50 and recognizes these numbers by sight. A teacher who understands
the child's talent could offer encouragement to undertake an art project
involving the theme of numbers (e.g., drawing objects or animals in multiples,
then counting them, making designs out of numbers, exploring the relationships
between numbers through art, etc.). This integration of subject areas also
makes learning possible in multiple directions and allows young children
to develop talents in different content areas.
ASSESSING AND DOCUMENTING DEVELOPMENT
Like identification, assessment should be ongoing. Teachers can use
tests, class assignments, observations, informal interviews, consultations
with parents, and portfolios to assess how the children are doing. However,
they are only meaningful if conducted repeatedly over time and within a
variety of classroom activities and projects. In this way, teachers gain
a more comprehensive understanding of their students' talents and can create
further learning opportunities for their development.
Early identification and intervention are essential for the growth and
development of young gifted children. Equipped with practical teaching
strategies and creative resources, classroom teachers are in a unique position
to advance their talents in a stimulating environment of original thinking
and discovery. A sensitivity to the special needs of young gifted children
can make a significant difference to their future development and happiness.
Clark, B. (1992). Growing Up Gifted: Developing the Potential of Children
at Home and at School, 4th ed. New York: Maxwell Macmillan International.
Kingore, B. (1993). Portfolios: Enriching and Assessing All Students,
Identifying the Gifted, Grades K-6. DesMoines, IA: Leadership Publishers.
Smutny, J. F. (Ed.) (1998). The Young Gifted Child: Potential and Promise,
An Anthology. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
Smutny, J. F., Walker, S. Y., and Meckstroth, E. A. (1997). Teaching
Young Gifted Children in the Regular Classroom: Identifying, Nurturing,
and Challenging Ages 4-9. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit Publishing Inc.
Winebrenner, S. (1992). Teaching Gifted Kids in the Regular Classroom.
Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit Publishing Inc.