ERIC Identifier: ED460191
Publication Date: 2001-12-00
Author: Schwartz, Wendy
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Urban Education New York NY.
Closing the Achievement Gap: Principles for Improving the
Educational Success of All Students. ERIC Digest.
School efforts to close the gap in academic achievement between ethnic and
racial minority students and white students have been largely unsuccessful to
date; differences in educational performance persist at all achievement levels,
with the gap greatest between students of color and immigrants and their white
and Asian American peers at high achievement levels. The need for a solution to
this problem has new urgency now--here in the increasingly diverse United
States--as the relationship between educational success and social and economic
opportunity steadily strengthens and the relationship between educational
differences and social conflict becomes more manifest.
Fortunately, there is now also greater potential for closing the achievement
gap as a new resolve to do so takes hold. An upsurge in concrete steps to
improve minority achievement in schools across the nation is encouraging, since
the efforts are knowledge based--informed by the existence of proven and
promising strategies and by new research pointing to additional innovative
measures. Moreover, it is now widely recognized that schools, communities, and
families must be committed to the achievement of all children, must begin
educating them when they are very young, and must make a long-term commitment to
educational improvement. Creating an overall atmosphere for children that
reflects these principles is becoming a priority nationally, and a wide range of
supportive resources are being deployed.
This digest briefly reviews the educational policies and practices whose
effectiveness in closing the achievement gap has been shown, and provides a list
of resources offering detailed information about them. One resource is the
Internet pathway, Closing the Achievement Gap, developed by the ERIC
Clearinghouse on Urban Education, on which the digest is based. Previously
published Clearinghouse digests also cover some of the specific principles in
more depth, and future digests will explore additional principles.
STATE AND DISTRICT ROLE
* Development and implementation of
education goals which reflect the desires, needs, and values of the public,
schools, and parents, and which will generate a shared commitment to education
* Development and implementation of rigorous standards that form the basis of
curriculum development and instructional practice, specify students'
competencies by subject and grade, and define the performance and
responsibilities of school administrators and teachers.
* Development and implementation of accountability standards to ensure the
high quality and good performance of all administrators and educators.
* Dissemination of existing researched-based instructional programs with
demonstrated success to individual schools for adaption, as appropriate, and
dissemination of information about effective instructional strategies and
exemplary practices that are especially effective in diverse classrooms.
* Provision of human and material resources necessary for successful student
* Provision of opportunities for sharing information, experiences, and
problem solving across schools and levels.
EARLY CHILDHOOD DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVES
* Provision of high
quality preschool programs that foster young children's development of social
and school readiness skills, develop their interest in learning, and orient them
toward academic achievement; and active recruitment of families to a local
* Provision of parent education programs, social service resources, and,
possibly, financial support to help families learn how to make a concrete
commitment to their children's academic success while they are still very young,
to teach families to promote children's cognitive and social development and
improve their homes as a learning environment, and to encourage families to take
advantage of school and community resources that support achievement.
* Provision of family literacy programs.
* Active promotion of the expectation that
all students can succeed, the demand that they do so, and encouragement to
prepare for higher education.
* Maintenance of a school climate conducive to academic productivity by
orienting students' attitudes and behavior to excellence and giving them a sense
of efficacy and power, and by directing their time to productive academic
exercises, such as inquiry, seeking and using help, and learning.
* Identification and development of every student's potential through
individualized assessments, appropriate placements, and ongoing encouragement
from school staff.
* Recognition of diverse cultures as components of the mainstream and
establishment of a balance between students' native ways of communicating,
learning, and behaving and the need for them to be educated, contribute
positively to the school environment, and develop the skills for professional
and social success in adulthood.
* Maintenance of a safe and orderly school where staff and students
demonstrate respect for each other and are free of fear; and where the code of
conduct is well-publicized, fair, and uniformly enforced.
* Full desegregation of all school
classes, programs, and extracurricular activities.
* Smaller classes, preferably with 18 or fewer students and particularly in
the earlier grades.
* Equitable grouping of students that places students of color, in proportion
to their numbers, in high ability classes in the early grades and in higher
tracks and college preparatory classes in high school.
TEACHING AND LEARNING
* Provision of increased
instructional time in reading, mathematics, and other basic skills.
* Use of challenging curricula and instructional strategies that engage
students' interest, promote inquiry and discovery, and provide students with a
sense of satisfaction from their own efforts.
* Provision of learning resources, such as reading specialists; computer
technology and staff trained in its use; and books for a student library,
advanced textbooks, consumable workbooks, and other high quality print
* Operation of magnet high schools and special subject-specific programs to
promote learning by tapping into students' particular interests.
* Provision of supplemental individualized education supports, including
tutoring by professionals or trained adult volunteers and peers; after-school,
weekend, and summer programs; and intensive in-school aid for retained students.
* Provision of access to college-based programs and professionals who can
serve as role models and mentors.
* Application of in-depth, appropriate, and ongoing assessments of the
performance and progress of each student--including grades, test scores,
classroom behavior, extracurricular activities, and conduct--to determine class
and program placement and the types of individual supports should be given.
* Recruitment and retention of
experienced, well-qualified teachers for students at all ability levels, who
have excellent teaching skills and a good command of their subject specialties
and are held accountable for students' performance.
* Recruitment and retention of high-performing administrators who provide
pedagogical leadership, require the preparedness and efficacy of the teachers,
and are held accountable for all their responsibilities.
* Provision of required ongoing professional development to help teachers
master new curricula and teaching strategies, especially those effective in
diverse classrooms; improve students' ability to meet standards; treat and
challenge all students equally; internalize and convey the fact that race and
ethnicity do not affect achievement; and share and solve problems.
* Application of state-, district-, and school-developed standards to
curriculum and instruction design, student assessment, and teacher evaluation.
* Decision making based on data collection and analysis, including review of
schoolwide data--current and past test scores, course enrollment patterns, and
disciplinary actions--and a comparison of the data with those of other students,
schools, and areas to help determine what overall school changes are likely to
improve student performance.
* Active encouragement of parents' high
expectations for their children's achievement, involvement in their children's
schooling, development of a home atmosphere conducive to learning, participation
in homework completion, and commitment to help them meet performance standards,
through social functions, meetings, and workshops where the family role in
educational success is described.
* Encouragement of parents' participation in school events through a decrease
in barriers by provision of babysitting, a meal, transportation aid, etc.
* Provision of education, health, and social services to students and their
parents, preferably in a central location, via a case management approach.
* Maintenance of a culture where learning and achievement are valued that is
sustained and supported by religious and social organizations and the media.
* Provision of learning opportunities at local libraries, museums, and other
* Provision of coordinated services designed to support students' educational
achievement and their parents' ability to foster their children's learning, such
as physical and mental health care, adult education, and financial assistance.
* Maintenance of active school partnerships that include helping schools link
families with local social services; providing students with mentors, tutors,
and role models; providing parents with adult basic skills education, job
training, and parenting classes; and fund raising to increase the resources
available to local schools.
* Organization of leisure activities with an academic focus.
Efforts to close the achievement gap have
intensified in the last several years, and the experiences of districts and
school with notable successes are beginning to appear in the education
An excellent source for these reports is the ERIC database. The world's most
extensive collection of materials on education, the database is a component of
the ERIC system, a national information service funded by the Office of
Educational Research and Improvement of the U.S. Department of Education. The
ERIC database can be accessed on the Internet: http://askeric.org/Eric/.%20
Some of these reports, along with additional research-based informational
materials, can be accessed through the ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban Education's
pathway, Closing the Achievement Gap, on its web site, UEweb:
One specific publication series worth noting consists of a national and
state-by-state statistical representation and comparison of the achievement gap:
2001 Education Trust State Summaries, was prepared by The Education Trust,
Washington, DC, and produced for EdWatch Online (www.edtrust.org).