ERIC Identifier: ED470033
Publication Date: 2002-11-00
Author: Curtis, Donnelyn - Yue, Paoshan
Clearinghouse on Information and Technology Syracuse NY.
Acquiring and Managing Electronic Journals. ERIC Digest.
Electronic journals are both a blessing and a curse for libraries. To be
meaningful in the current information environment - to meet users'
ever-increasing demands - libraries must acquire as many appropriate full text
resources as possible, as quickly as possible, and make them easy to use. This
Digest provides tips for acquiring and providing access to electronic journals
through a library's Web site and online catalog. We encourage readers to consult
some of the Web sites and other resources we listed for detailed advice on
licensing and technical matters, such as user authentication.
Staff enthusiasm is crucial for maintaining the momentum to solve workflow
problems and overcome technical obstacles in managing e-journals. The positive
attitude of library staff also helps users adjust to online library services. It
is easy to get excited on behalf of users about access to e-journals, which
Are available day or night, anywhere, to multiple concurrent users
Support distance education and web-based instruction
Allow the library to reach remote and disabled researchers
Can be searched, browsed, and interlinked with other publications and
Are generally more current than print publications
Provide opportunities for enrichment and augmentation not possible in the print
The benefits to libraries, while numerous, are less immediate. Space
requirements and staff time will be saved when print journals are no longer
needed, and e-journals can provide a great deal more direct access to quality
information. Public relations opportunities are enormous.
Plunge in! Libraries can no longer afford to hold back. It is expensive for
journal publishers and libraries to maintain two formats. When e-journals become
ubiquitous, publishers and libraries will be able to devote their resources to
producing and providing access to online-only journals. That day is coming, and
libraries can help shorten the painful transition period.
You will need a flexible staff and organizational structure. Electronic
journals impact areas of the library that have had little involvement with the
management of print serials, and new demands on staff will require you to
redefine positions and re-prioritize work. In order to better manage e-journals
at the University of Nevada, Reno, the Serials Department no longer checks in or
binds most print journals. They represent a dwindling proportion of our
periodicals and are much less heavily used than our e-journals.
If your library's static or shrinking budget
has kept you from exploring options for e-journals, you might be surprised to
find that you can provide access to hundreds if not thousands of e-journals
without spending any extra money by compiling URLs of journals already
available. If you have discretionary funds or you can redirect funds from other
kinds of materials (such as microforms) you could provide 10,000 or more
e-journals, especially if your library belongs to a consortium.
Any library can present links to free e-journals, many of which have been
established as online-only publications. You might be surprised at their quality
and abundance. To find them, visit the Web sites of libraries that have already
compiled lists. The University of Nevada, Reno Library provides access to 267
free e-journals. The Google search "Free Electronic Journals" or "Free Online
Journals" can help you find other library lists.
Aggregator databases were designed for the subject-oriented search and
retrieval of articles from multiple sources. But thanks to pressure from
libraries, many of them now include cover-to-cover, full-text coverage of
journals, providing table-of-content access through stable URLs. If you
subscribe to full text databases from EBSCO, ProQuest and other vendors, you can
make direct links to journals in the databases, bypassing the search interface.
Note that, in some cases, a publisher embargo blocks access to recent issues.
Back issues of many high quality Science/Technology/Medical (STM) journals
are freely available on the Web. Highwire Press currently hosts 439,369 free
full-text articles from around 200 journals. Other initiatives derive revenue
from authors instead of readers. BioMed Central is one such source of over 120
freely available current biomedical journals.
Some publishers give free or very inexpensive online access to their print
subscribers. Your serials agent (EBSCO, Faxon, Swets, and so on) can send you a
list of your subscriptions that include free online access. You could also use
OCLC's Electronic Collections Online (ECO) "Publisher and Journal Info" list to
identify publishers that provide free online access with print subscriptions
through ECO, whether or not you plan to provide access to them through the ECO
Several publishers provide packages of all their electronic journals at a
reasonable cost. Unlike print subscriptions, the cost for online licenses can
vary a great deal from library to library. Publishers often tailor the price to
an institution's budget, based on anticipated or real use. A common model uses
the library's print subscriptions to derive a price for a publisher's complete
online package. So if your library has been through major journal cancellations
or has a very small budget, you might be able to gain electronic access to
hundreds or thousands of journals for a small fraction of their list price. In
negotiating with publishers, explain your library's finances.
Many library consortia sprang to life in the late 1990s. Most publishers like
to negotiate with one person on behalf of many libraries, and through offering
dramatic group discounts, they can get their journals into more libraries than
ever before. A larger customer base does not multiply production costs as it
does for print journals. More visibility and higher citation rates ultimately
increase the value of a publisher's journals, so sometimes small libraries will
be granted access to a large package through a consortium at practically no
additional cost. If you do not participate in a consortial buying club, consider
affiliating with one in a neighboring state. Sometimes an ad hoc consortium will
form to obtain a discount from one publisher.
One final option to consider is to pass e-journal costs on to users through a
"pay-per-view" service provided by vendors such as ingenta, First Search, or
EBSCO; or to activate and subsidize a mediated or unmediated article-delivery
feature using a deposit account.
In the online world, as in the print world, library
users approach journals in three distinct ways. They are looking for (1)
articles on a certain subject, regardless of the sources, (2) articles already
identified, or (3) the entire contents of specific journals (usually recent
Libraries need to support all these approaches by providing easy access to
journal contents. In doing so, libraries must intelligently choose their
e-journal access approaches, depending on the user needs and the available
resources of staff and time.
WEB PAGES AND WEB-BASED ONLINE CATALOG
Access to e-journals
is generally provided through Web pages and/or Web-based online catalogs. A Web
page of e-journal titles, which can be created with minimal Web authoring
skills, is the most basic and simple way to provide access. It is a first step
in connecting your users to your e-journal collection. Incorporating e-journals
into the online catalog requires cataloging expertise. However, it has
advantages over Web pages such as connecting with print (or other formats) and
providing comprehensive bibliographic access to all resources. It is common for
libraries to adopt both means to provide multiple types of access to all their
If your library decides to provide access
through both Web pages and the online catalog, you need to think about your
The two-database approach is used when the Web pages and the catalog entries
are maintained separately. Apart from maintaining the catalog entries, libraries
must decide a suitable mechanism for generating the Web pages. Some libraries
maintain an HTML file in a Web design program, such as FrontPage or DreamWeaver.
Some libraries store their e-journal data in a spreadsheet program such as Excel
or a database program such as Access and convert them into Web pages. Examples
are the sites for the University of Nevada Reno and the Oklahoma State
University. Some other libraries use a relational database to generate
sophisticated Web-based interactive access. Examples are the sites for the
University of North Carolina at Greensboro and the Massachusetts Institute of
The one-database approach is used when a library populates its Web pages and
online catalog from one central database. It is only natural for libraries to
choose the online catalog as the central database for this project. After all,
adequately cataloged e-journal entries offer full spectrum of access points, and
libraries are known to have cataloging expertise. In this model, e-journal data
is extracted from the online catalog to generate Web pages on the fly. Examples
are the sites of Los Alamos National Laboratory and Miami University. A variant
version of the one-database approach is to use Excel or Access to generate both
Web pages and batches of brief MARC records. Most catalogers would not approve
of this as a way to populate a catalog, but it is a fast way to put records
there. It would definitely eliminate the single-record possibility, which will
be discussed below, but it may be considered as a good first attempt.
Many libraries that started early in providing access to e-journals began
with the two-database approach. Some of them have now switched or are switching
to the one-database approach. The main reasons are: (1) to cut down the staff
time needed for Web page maintenance; (2) to provide consistent information
across multiple access points; and (3) to increase the accuracy and timeliness
of the data. A library still at an early stage of providing e-journal access
should seriously consider using the one-database approach.
LEVELS OF ACCESS
The most basic form of Web page access is
an alphabetical list of titles with links. To enhance access, libraries may add
coverage dates, publishers, usage restrictions, subject groupings, title and
subject search engines, and other information deemed useful for the user
As for the online catalog, full cataloging is common for "stable" e-journals
such as publishers' titles while minimal cataloging may be considered for less
"stable" titles, such as the ones available via full-text databases, if they are
included in the catalog at all. When a library owns the print counterpart of an
e-journal title, there is yet another decision to make. Will the "single-record"
or "separate-record" approach be used? When the "single-record" approach is
used, e-journal data and link are added to the bibliographic record for the
print version. When the "separate-record" approach is used, the e-journal title
receives its own bibliographic record. A library should decide which approach to
use according to local needs.
The emerging OpenURL standard provides an exciting
opportunity for libraries to bring electronic resources closer to the users.
With the OpenURL, libraries can connect reference citations in index databases
to a variety of services available for the particular citations. Those services
may include one or more full-text sources, searching the library catalog,
searching a regional or national database, initiating an interlibrary loan (ILL)
request, asking a librarian, or searching for related information on the
author(s) and journals. A library needs to have a local OpenURL resolver and a
selection of OpenURL-enabled resources before providing this type of
context-sensitive reference linking service. This extremely valuable access
service option is definitely worth librarians' attention.
There is always the option of outsourcing.
Available products include A-Z lists for full-text database titles, including
holdings and regular updates, MARC records ready for batch loads, title and
subject search engines on Web pages, and other e-journal management related
services. TDNet, Serials Solutions, and EBSCO host Electronic Journals Service
are just a few companies among many available outsourcing services.
RELATED WEB SITES
BioMed Central www.biomedcentral.com
Harrassowitz, Otto. Electronic Journals: A Selected Resource Guide.
Highwire Press highwire.stanford.edu
Hunt, Steve. Remote User Authentication in Libraries. library.smc.edu/rpa.htm
Los Alamos National Laboratory. Electronic Journals.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Vera: Virtual Electronic Resource
Miami University. Electronic Journals. www.lib.muohio.edu/research/ejournals
OCLC Electronic Collections Online. Publisher and Journal Info. Participating
Oklahoma State University. Full-Text Periodical Titles and Coverage List.
University of Nevada, Reno. Electronic Journals.
University of Nevada, Reno. Unrestricted Electronic Journals, A-Z.
University of North Carolina at Greensboro. Journal Finder.
Brandsma, T. W., Bernhardt, E. R., & Sally, D. M. (2002). Journal Finder: A solution for comprehensive and unmediated
access to journal articles. Serials Review, 28 (1): 13-20.
Curtis, D., Scheschy, V. M., & Tarango, A. R. (2000). Developing and
managing electronic journal collections: A how-to-do-it manual for librarians.
New York: Neal-Schuman Publishers.
Hennig, N. (2002). Improving access to e-journals and databases at the MIT
Libraries: Building a database-backed web site called "Vera." Serials Librarian,
41 (3/4): 227-254.
Needleman, M. (2002). The OpenURL: An emerging standard for linking. Serials
Review, 28 (1): 74-76.
Rich, L. A., & Rabine, J. L. (2001). The changing access to electronic
journals: A survey of academic library websites revisited. Serials Review, 27