ERIC Identifier: ED303177
Publication Date: 1988-05-00
Author: Schamber, Linda
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Information Resources Syracuse NY.
Technology Options for Libraries. ERIC Digest.
If anyone is subject to information overload these days, it is the
information professional. Library administrators and librarians, inundated with
news about new technologies, may be torn between the desire to develop
state-of-the-art facilities and the need to stay within a limited budget. Even
given an unlimited budget, it is not clear how tomorrow's library could or
should look. This digest will outline some of the technological trends, and
discuss administrative issues and strategies for updating the library.
Over the last few decades, the focus of
libraries has shifted from digitization of information, to automation of library
functions, to integration of library systems. The current trend toward
integration extends beyond local area networks to the concept of a wholly
integrated information environment. This environment involves not only the
immediate community--city, campus, business--but state, national, and
international resources. Integration is the byword at every level of library
activity. It is evident in: o
networks; o o o
intelligence and hypermedia programs; o o o o
None of these concepts is new, but they represent a mind-boggling set of
technological options for the library administrator to consider. One way to cope
is not to try to envision a vast electronic network, but to look at the ultimate
goal of the library: serving the user. For the user, the integrated information
network can make life remarkably simple. All he or she has to do is log onto a
microcomputer at an institutional workstation (or log on from home), read a menu
of applications options, and click a mouse. In almost no time, he or she can be
accessing, creating, processing, sending, or storing information. The files can
be any size, any format, anywhere. The most important part of this picture is
that the user is not really aware of the network structure at all.
Of course it's a long haul from most of today's
libraries to that ideal vision. For the library administrator, the technical,
human, and financial issues are complex.
Technical issues involve matters of access and delivery, or more
specifically, choosing among a myriad of hardware and software options. The
microcomputer is ubiquitous; with various peripherals and software, it can
complement or replace many mainframe functions. With the potential of networking
both inside and outside the library, the administrator must also consider the
compatibility of systems, in terms both of linkable hardware and of software
that can search different databases and facilitate applications such as word
processing and desktop publishing. At best, only educated guesses can now be
made as to which systems in a very new and competitive market will become
standards. In fact, research and development are at such a competitive and
formative stage that users themselves are having a great deal of input.
Human issues involve the changing roles and status of library personnel and
library patrons. In libraries with end-user workstations, librarians tend to
spend more time training patrons in database search skills and dealing with
increased expectations for the quantity and quality of information. In academic
settings, the librarian is likely to be more involved in curriculum development
and in the networking of various computerized instruction programs, such as
interactive television. Library personnel generally must learn to deal with
computerized indexing, cataloging, and reference systems, online retrieval,
accounting and other administrative database management, and interpersonal
electronic communication systems. The administrator must not only consider these
changes, but also work actively to educate personnel and to elicit their
The financial issues may be the hardest of all. Initial investments are high.
Should the library dive into new technologies now, or wait for continued
improvement of products and lowering of prices? It is difficult to foresee what
"bugs" exist in new products, and to predict what enhancements and different
products will be available next month. There are at present no guarantees as to
consistency of services, compatibility of systems, or continuing support by
vendors. Market relationships are changing as vendors combine publishing,
distribution, and maintenance responsibilities, and as specialized industries
develop. Somehow the library administrator must come up with creative
strategies, often tradeoffs, for integrating new with existing technologies and
The first step, obviously, is to become
informed. At least four dozen periodicals cover new technologies in general and
library applications in particular. Articles include management advice, case
studies, and product reviews and advertising. Professional organizations sponsor
conferences and workshops devoted to specific technological issues. Much current
information concerns CD-ROM database services, but the strategies for evaluating
and introducing CD-ROM can easily apply to other technologies. Contact vendors
directly, and other institutions that are upgrading their systems.
Second, know thyself. What are your patrons' needs? How well do you currently
meet these needs? Make a detailed needs assessment of your personnel,
collections, services, hardware, and space.
Third, establish the project with a task force and project manager. Solicit
input from library personnel at all levels: the more involved employees are, the
more likely they are to support and promote change. Work systematically to
create a detailed planning document that covers all aspects of the proposed
improvements. Begin by considering requirements and writing objectives. Outline
selection criteria for hardware and software. Make cost analyses and devise a
timetable for implementation. Consider alternative implementation plans. Outline
project testing and evaluation procedures. Address issues such as training,
publicity, and security, and user policies such as fees.
Be thorough, looking to long-range as well as short-range planning, with room
for change. Cost analyses should include more than prices: consider the terms of
database subscriptions, and whether various contracts include delivery,
installation, user documentation and training, service, and maintenance.
Implementation plans may include multistage introduction of various
technologies, hybrid systems, tradeoffs between new and existing systems, and
joint programs with other institutions. Special attention should be paid to how
pilot projects are set up and evaluations conducted.
The decision to introduce new technologies has
never been simple. It seems that the information professional needs both a
cogent overview of the present and a sensible vision of the future in order not
to be overwhelmed by the many tempting options. Only through systematic study
and planning can he or she be reasonably selective. But whether the decision is
to take the plunge or wait and see, the market is developing apace. It is
becoming necessary to change just to hold one's position. And obtaining the
right technology is not enough: the overall environment must be considered.
Penniman (1987) reports that more than 70% of information innovations that fail
in the marketplace fail for nontechnical reasons involving marketing,
management, capitalization, or organizations themselves. On the other hand, new
technologies and media are not replacing, only enhancing the old, and responses
to innovations such as CD-ROM database services have been enthusiastic.
The Online Computer Library Center (OCLC)
offers a number of publications--often free--for its member libraries and for
independent institutions. Call (800) 848-5878 ext. 4372, or write OCLC, MC 142,
6565 Frantz Road, Dublin, OH 43017. Two publications of particular interest:
o A detailed report of the results of the 1987 OCLC and Users Council Library
Strategic Planning Survey. More than 2,200 libraries responded, with more than
200 submitting strategic plans for internal and external use. Plans cover
automation, services, staffing, collections, facilities, and funding. For
information call the Users Council Office, OCLC.
o Communications & Access Planning Guide is designed for OCLC member
libraries to use in evaluating their service, terminal, microcomputer
workstation, and access situations with an eye to making decisions on future
service and equipment. Included are case studies, a directory of OCLC services,
a table of equipment requirements, and worksheets. Guides have been distributed
to member libraries and are also available from network offices. Independent
institutions can contact the OCLC Library Liaison Officer.
Holibaugh, Ralph. (1987). OPTICAL DISCS FOR STORAGE AND ACCESS IN ARL
LIBRARIES. SPEC KIT 133. Washington, DC: Association of Research Libraries,
Office of Management Studies. ED 283 534 (microfiche only), or order from ARL,
1527 New Hampshire Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20036 ($20.00). The 128-page kit
contains excerpts from technical, planning and evaluation documents contributed
by 40 ARL member libraries, summaries of interviews with ARL members, a glossary
of terms, a 10-item reading list, and SPEC kit evaluation and order forms.
Recommended periodicals: Advanced Technology/Libraries, CD-ROM Librarian,
Database, Library Hi Tech, Library Hi Tech News, Online, Optical Data Systems,
Optical Information Systems, Optical Information Systems Update, Optical
Information Systems Update/Library and Information Center Applications, and
T.H.E. Journal: Technical Horizons in Education.
Bogue, David T. (1987, April). The information challenge and the Film/Computer/Optical Age. INFORM, 1(4), 14-16.
Chen, Ching-chih. (1986,
December). Libraries in the Information Age: Where are the microcomputer and laser optical disc technologies taking us? MICROCOMPUTERS FOR INFORMATION MANAGEMENT, 3(4), 253-265.
Co, Francisca. (1987, November). CD-ROM systems: Problems and prospects. SMALL COMPUTERS IN LIBRARIES, 7(10), 42-44, 46-49.
Norman. (1987, November-December). Managing a laserbase project OPTICAL INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 7(6), 377-380.
Ferguson, Douglas K.
(ed.). (1987). Electronic information delivery systems: Reports on five projects sponsored by The Fred Meyer
Charitable Trust. LIBRARY HIGH TECH, 18/5(2), 65-93.
Hoffman, Ellen. (1988).
(Managing automation: A process, not a project. LIBRARY HI TECH, 21/6(1), 45-54.
Jackson, Kathy M., King, Evelyn M., &
Kellough, Jean. (1988, March). How to organize an extensive laserdisk installation: The Texas A&M experience. ONLINE, 12(2), 51-60.
Mellinger, Michael J. (1987).
ATLAS from Data Research Associates: A fully integrated automation system. LIBRARY HI TECH, 17/5(1), 53-58.
Merck, Edwin & Fleit, Linda. (1988, February-March). Is higher education too old for technology? THE EDUTECH REPORT, 3(11), 1, 4-5; and 3(12), 3, 6-7.
Penniman, W. David. (1987, Summer). Tomorrow's
library today. SPECIAL LIBRARIES, 78(3), 195-205.
Saviers, Shannon Smith. (1987, Fall).
Reflections on CD-ROM: Bridging the gap between technology and purpose. SPECIAL LIBRARIES, 78(4), 288-294.
Swan, John. (1988, February 1). Information and
madness. LIBRARY JOURNAL, 113(2), 25-28.
Tucker, Sandra L., Anders, Vicki, Clark, Katherine
E., & Kinyon, William R. (1988, May). How to manage an extensive laserdisk installation: The Texas A&M experience. ONLINE, 12(3), 34-46.
Vandergrift, Kay E., Kemper, Marlyn, Champion, Sandra, & Hannigan, Jane Anne. (1987, August). CD-ROM: An emerging technology. Part 2: Planning and management strategies. SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL, 33(11), 22-25.
Whelan, Errol A. & Chan, Jeanie. (1988, January-February). Computerizing a high school library. LIBRARY SOFTWARE REVIEW 7(1), 12-16.