ERIC Identifier: ED315703
Publication Date: 1990-00-00
Author: Ellis, Thomas I.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Counseling and Personnel Services Ann Arbor MI.
Counselors and Teachers as Student Advisors. Highlights: An
Amid all the recent flurry of state and national reports calling for
educational reform initiatives to raise academic standards, add course
requirements, require competency testing, and otherwise upgrade the quality of
our schools, very little attention has been given to the need for improved
guidance and counseling services. Yet effective learning can take place only
within a supportive environment, of which developmental guidance is a crucial
When students have problems, they turn to those whom they know the best, and
who they think can help the most. Surveys have shown that the adults to whom
students of all ages are most likely to turn, after their parents, are teachers.
A teacher advisor program (TAP) is therefore one very effective way of directly
involving teachers in developmental guidance.
WHY DO SCHOOLS NEED A TEACHER ADVISOR PROGRAM?
schools, there are far from enough school counselors or others specialists to
provide a comprehensive program for developmental guidance.
As it is, counselors' hands are normally full as a result of dealing with
high-risk students who have special needs or emotional problems, and most other
students are lucky if they can gain access to a counselor more than a few times
during a school year. Yet all students, especially at the middle school level,
need the support of a friendly adult who cares about them personally; someone
they can confide in, who can help them deal with the problems of growing up,
keeping up with their studies, and planning their careers.
ARE TEACHERS QUALIFIED TO PROVIDE COUNSELING?
may lack the professional training of counselors, school teachers have a long
tradition of helping students with personal problems. They also interact with
the students daily, and thus are in an excellent position to provide personal
direction. In fact, effective teachers share many of the same traits as
effective counselors: ability to empathize with students, patience and
flexibility, excellent interpersonal skills, openness to new ideas, and
awareness of individual differences. Good teachers also habitually promote and
sustain positive group interaction in their classes, and develop a helping
relationship with both students and parents. In all these ways, the teacher's
role is closely allied to that of the counselor.
Elementary school teachers, who work closely with young children in a single
classroom, generally accept the idea that developmental guidance is an integral
part of their responsibility to students. But middle and secondary school
teachers work with a larger number of students and usually spend no more than an
hour a day with each class. Because their teaching is limited to specialized
fields, they tend to emphasize academic skills, and have little time to spend
getting to know their students or talking about students' needs, interests, or
problems. Yet adolescents at the middle and high school level need personal
attention and guidance as much as, if not more than, young children. A trusted
high school teacher is often the student's first choice as someone to turn to in
discussing personal problems.
WHAT WOULD A TEACHER ADVISOR PROGRAM INVOLVE?
especially in middle schools and high schools, often feel so overwhelmed with
their schedules and responsibilities that they do not have the time to build
close personal relationships with their students. To be successful, a teacher
advisor program must therefore be incorporated as a part of the regular
curriculum. One popular approach has been to assign each teacher 15-20 advisees,
and to arrange regular "homebase" or "homeroom" periods of 25-30 minutes at the
beginning of each school day. The teacher then devotes at least two sessions per
week to developmental guidance activities, during which students can explore
their personal interests, goals, and concerns with a supportive group of peers.
Teacher-advisors also hold regular student and parent conferences and keep track
of their advisees' academic progress, consulting with other teachers, school
counselors, and support personnel.
WHAT SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN A GUIDANCE CURRICULUM?
developmental guidance curriculum can be structured to include units that focus
on the following themes:
- getting acquainted/orientation
- study skills and habits
- communication skills
- decision-making and problem-solving
- peer relationships
- conflict resolution
- personal hygiene and wellness
- career awareness and development
- educational planning
- community involvement
These units may be organized sequentially according to a school guidance
calendar and the major events of the school year. For example, orientation and
study skills units would be scheduled early in the year to allow students to get
to know the school and one another, and to get off on the right track
academically. A self-assessment unit would follow, enabling the students to map
out their personal strengths and identify the areas where they need to grow.
While some of these topics can be covered in a single class period (such as
"getting acquainted"), others can become recurrent focal points for group
discussion, such as motivation, conflict resolution, communication skills, and
Some sessions should be carefully structured to build group cohesiveness or
to introduce important developmental concepts. Other sessions should be left
open-ended, allowing discussion to focus on students' particular interests and
WHAT IS THE COUNSELOR'S ROLE IN TAP?
Although some teachers
and counselors alike fear that TAP is simply a strategy for getting teachers to
take over counselors' work, it is important to emphasize that teacher-advisors
can never be a substitute for professional school counselors. Rather, in a
well-designed program, the respective roles of teachers and counselors must be
clearly identified. An understanding needs to be reached, for example, that
teachers will refer students with special needs to counselors, instead of
attempting to handle students' complex emotional or behavioral problems on their
Teachers can also collaborate with counselors by inviting them to address
their classes on special topics; such visits will create a visible bond between
teachers and counselors, and thus dissuade students from attempting to play one
off against the other. Furthermore, counselors can assist teachers who are
having trouble managing their groups by modeling group guidance skills and
serving as consultants to the teachers. In fact, counselors often assume
leadership roles in TAP, coordinating the teachers and providing resources for
WILL TEACHERS SUPPORT TAP?
In spite of the advantages of a
Teacher Advisor Program, many teachers are reluctant to support such a program,
because they are either skeptical about its utility or wary of the extra
preparation that such a program would involve. Robert D. Myrick estimates, for
example, that in most schools 20% of the teachers would immediately support such
a program while 20% would be strongly opposed. It is therefore important to move
the middle 60% toward supporting TAP and developmental guidance.
If most teachers are to support a Teacher Advisor Program, they must clearly
understand and embrace the essential concepts of developmental guidance
underlying the program and the curricular goals. They also need preparation in
guidance and interpersonal skills, so that they can effectively facilitate class
discussions that help students think about personal problems and explore
alternative courses of action.
Second, if a TAP is to be anything more than a formality, the time commitment
needs to be adequate. Group meetings of once a week or less are not likely to
allow valuable helping relationships between teachers and their advisees to
develop, nor do they give teachers the opportunity to establish continuity or
consistency. TAP works best when it is scheduled every school day, or at least
two or three times a week; otherwise, teachers tend to view TAP as an added
encumbrance, peripheral to their major duties.
Besides an adequate allotment of time, TAP also must have a developmental
guidance curriculum with clearly articulated objectives, and with supporting
materials and activities that can stimulate student participation. If teachers
have an organized guidance handbook, which they are at liberty to follow, adapt,
or modify as they see fit, they are more likely to "buy into" the guidance
program as a whole.
Finally, teachers need to be assured of full support and cooperation from
both the administration and the counseling staff, so that they won't feel as if
the burden of student guidance has been unfairly shifted to their shoulders. For
this reason, TAP should be monitored and evaluated by students, teachers,
counselors, and administrators every year to ensure that the program is meeting
WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS OF TEACHERS AS ADVISORS?
Teacher Advisor Programs compensate for the high
counselor-student ratios that make it impossible for school counselors to know
all students personally. But beyond this compensatory role, TAP strengthens
teacher-student relationships and creates a supportive learning environment in
which teachers and counselors can work together to respond to students' academic
and personal needs.
The major disadvantage of Teacher Advisor Programs is that not all teachers
are able or willing to work effectively with students in an advisory role. Such
programs are therefore often viewed as a passing fad or an infringement on
To be successful, a Teacher Advisor Program must therefore have a clearly
defined purpose, reflected in a well-conceived curriculum, and it must enlist
the full support of administrators, teachers, and counselors alike.
Daresh, J. C., & Pautsch, T. R. (1983). A
successful teacher-advisor program. Middle School Journal, 14(3), 3-13.
Henderson, P., & LaForge, J. (1989). The role of the middle school counselor in teacher advisor programs. SchoolCounselor, 36(5), 348-351.
Myrick, R. D. (1987). Developmental guidance and counseling: A practical approach. Minneapolis: Educational Media Corporation.
Myrick, R. D., & Myrick, L. S. (1990). The teacher advisor program: An innovative approach to school guidance. Ann Arbor, MI: ERIC Counseling and Personnel Services Clearinghouse, The University of Michigan.