ERIC Identifier: ED320138
Publication Date: 1990-07-00
Author: Sensenbaugh, Roger
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Reading and Communication Skills Bloomington IN.
Multiplicities of Literacies in the 1990s. ERIC Digest.
A number of phrases incorporating the word literacy have been used in the
documents entered into the ERIC database in the past few years. These phrases
include computer literacy, scientific literacy, literacy acquisition, emerging
or emergent literacy, visual literacy, cultural literacy, and literacy
instruction. Closely allied to these "literacies" are terms referring to
computer uses in education, second language acquisition, influence of the home
environment on students, the whole language approach, and literacy in business
THE BROADENING SCOPE OF LITERACY
Out of this proliferation
of literacies, one important aspect for reading, English, and language arts
teachers concerns teaching methods which incorporate the broadening scope of
literacy. A common theme in these documents is that literacy is more than just
being able to read and write; it is the ability to comprehend, interpret,
analyze, respond, and interact with the growing variety of complex sources of
information. Calfee (1986) discusses the concept of literacy and how programs
should be designed to help children from disadvantaged backgrounds acquire
literacy. He includes a description of current curricula and presents tentative
recommendations for policy changes at all levels. On a more practical level,
McCracken and McCracken (1986) discuss stories, songs, and poetry as part of the
repertoire of instructional techniques for developing literacy.
Some documents report on the implementation of a comprehensive program of
literacy education (Snow, Palladino, and Engel, 1987) while others provide the
programs themselves (Graves, 1982). Milz (1987), for example, discusses how
teachers can implement the deeper understanding of literacy development that
research has offered.
ACQUISITION OF LITERACIES
Literacy acquisition, that is,
the ways in which learners acquire literacy, is important for its instructional
implications and for its impact on the way that literacy itself is defined.
Observing how children make sense out of the world has taught researchers that
there is more to literacy than mastering isolated reading and writing skills.
Goodman (1985) argues that children growing up in literate societies begin to
read and write long before they start school. The interaction between a parent
and child acquiring literacy together is highlighted in studies of
intergenerational literacy. Hatch and Freeman (1987) discuss a striking
dichotomy between current theory and educational practice in the Ohio public
schools. Not only does current theory have a hard time breaking into the arena
of current practice, but current theorists are not of one mind when it comes to
exactly what research tells us.
As the scope of literacy expands,
confusion increases as to what exactly is meant by literacy. Venezky (1990),
while focusing on adult literacy, concludes with a discussion of the issues
surrounding a definition of literacy and presents a definition of his own.
Definitions of literacy also need to take into account the variety of cultures.
Hamilton-Wieler (1989) argues that different cultural agendas for literacy,
emerging from very different cultural histories, will require different
Graff (1987) provides a much needed historical perspective on the concept of
literacy. He argues that not only is the issue of literacy complex, it has
continuities and contradictions at its very core. Powell (1990), after
discussing the faddishness of writing and talking about literacy, argues that
the crucial issue is one of permanency: What does an individual have to do to be
As modern culture evolves, so also do the many forms of language within which
ways of thinking, working, negotiating, and reading with experience are encoded.
To be alert to how language works for creating and organizing meaning is to be
conscious of how to manipulate and use it. New technology, for example, demands
a greater degree of conscious reflection on its ways of working. (Christie,
EXPANDING THE DOMAIN
Clearly, literacy has broadened beyond
skills used in reading and writing to include terms in other disciplines. Butzow
and Butzow (1988) describe an approach to teaching scientific literacy by
integrating the subject matter from a variety of disciplines using children's
literature. Mitman, et al. (1985) focus specifically on the topic of scientific
literacy and provide teachers with background on the goals of science
instruction and practical recommendations for instructional practice.
The term media literacy is most often used to refer to TV watching habits.
Abelman (1987) investigates the effect of an in-school curriculum designed to
encourage children's awareness of and attention to television's prosocial
portrayals. Aiex (1989) summarizes research on mass media and offers suggestions
for developing media literacy in students.
Cultural literacy has entered the database as a consequence of Hirsch's work.
Computer literacy is included but appears under the more general term: computer
uses in education. Home literacy may become a new term due to the growing number
of citations that reflect on parental involvement in literacy acquisition, or
literacy in the home.
The definition of literacy has expanded well beyond that found in the scope
note of the 1988 ERIC Thesaurus: "literacy is the ability to read and write and
to communicate with written or printed symbols." Literacy involves making
meaning from a variety of sources and communicating it to a variety of
Graff's position on literacy may be the most constructive for the future:
"What is needed is a broader view of reading and writing that integrates and
emphasizes the many human abilities in a context of a changing world that
requires their development and use. Paths to learning individual literacy by the
young must be made less rigid; more attention must be paid to different
sequences and structure of learning; and more sensitivity must be shown toward
cultural and class influences."
Abelman, Robert. "TV Literacy II: Amplifying the
affective level effects of television's prosocial fare through curriculum intervention." Journal of Research and Development in Education, 20, 40-49, 1987. [ED 350 058]
Aiex, Nola Kortner. How to "read" television: Teaching students to view television critically. ERIC Digest. Bloomington, IN: ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and Communication Skills, 1989. [CS 506 766; ED number not yet assigned]
Butzow, Carol M., and John W. Butzow. "Science, technology and society as experienced through children's literature." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Science, Technology, and Society Conference on Technological Literacy, 1988. [ED 294 141]
Calfee, Robert. Curriculum and instruction: Reading. In Designs for compensatory education: Conference proceedings and papers, 1986. [ED 293 912]
Cases in Literacy: An Agenda for Discussion. Newark, DE: International Reading Association, 1989. [ED 311 407]
Christie, Frances. "The Changing Face of Literacy." In Christie, Frances (Ed.), Literacy for a Changing World, Australia: International Council for Educational Research, 1990, 1-25. [CS 010 126]
Graff, Harvey J. The Legacies of Literacy: Continuities and Contradictions in Western Culture and Society. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1987. [ED 311 395]
Graves, Michael F. The classroom teacher's role in reading instruction in the intermediate and secondary grades." 1982. [ED 249 212]
Hamilton-Wieler, Sharon. "Cultural Literacy Shock: A Drama in Three Acts." Paper presented at the Annual Spring Conference of the National Council of Teachers of English, 1989. [ED 310 400]
Hatch, J. Amos, and Evelyn B. Freeman. "Ohio kindergarten programs: Perspectives of teachers, principals, and supervisors." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, 1987. [ED 287 576]
McCracken, Robert A., and Marlene J. McCracken. Stories, songs, and poetry to teach reading and writing: Literacy through language. Chicago, IL: American Library Association, 1986. [ED 276 987]
Milz, Vera E. "Literacy: Learning and schooling." Insights into Open Education, 19., 1987. [ED 277 995]
Mitman, Alexis L., et al. What is scientific literacy? A guidebook for teachers of life sciences at the intermediate level. Intermediate Life Science Study Series, Volume I. San Francisco, CA: Far West Laboratory for Educational Research and Development, 1985. [ED 273 460]
Powell, William R. "Adult Literacy Programs of the Future." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Reading Association, 1990. [CS 010 024]
Snow, Mary B., et al. "Cambridge-Lesley literacy project: Theory, practice and evaluation." Paper presented at the 77th annual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of English, Los Angeles, CA, 1987. [ED 293 100]
Venezky, Richard L., et al. (Eds.). Toward Defining Literacy. Newark, DE: International Reading Association, 1990. [ED 313 677]