ERIC Identifier: ED268305
Publication Date: 1986-00-00
Author: Miller, Juliet V.
Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on
Adult Career and Vocational Education Columbus OH.
The Family-Career Connection. Overview. ERIC Digest No. 52.
Family and career roles are interrelated. Traditional sex roles have
influenced the nature of the family-career relationship. However, recent changes
in the family structure and in the work setting are creating pressures that
require families to redefine this relationship. This transition is still in
progress and is creating pressure on all family members.
Career development specialists in educational, community, private practice
and business-industry settings need to understand the basic concepts of family
and career and to become more effective in helping people integrate family and
career roles in ways that are satisfying both to themselves and to other family
WOMEN'S CAREER DEVELOPMENT
Traditional sex roles have been reflected in research. It is only recently
that research has addressed the nontraditional roles of men and women. First,
women in their career roles will be examined.
How Important Is Career For Women?
Miller (1984) cites a study finding that 87 percent of the women surveyed
derived a sense of personal accomplishment from work, and 58 percent indicated
that they prefer work outside the home to homemaking. Other research suggests
that most women will be employed outside the home at some time in their adult
lives and that work will have great importance in their lives.
What Are the Career Development Patterns of Women?
The career development patterns of women are varied and have traditionally
been influenced by the demands of the family. However, there is a trend toward
more consistent, long-term participation by women in the labor force. Several
writers have developed schemes to describe women's career patterns. Harmon
(1967) suggests five patterns: (1) no work experience, (2) work only until
marriage and/or birth of children, (3) combine work with marriage and/or
children, (4) reenter the labor force when children are older, and (5) remain
single and pursue career.
What Influences Women's Career Decisions?
Key career decisions include whether to have a career, which occupational
field to enter, and when to work. Variables that help predict men's career
decisions (interests, aptitudes, and career maturity) are less useful for
predicting women's career decisions. If this is true, what factors intervene to
modify this process? One factor is occupational stereotyping or normative views
of whether occupations are appropriate for men or women. The tendency for
women's career decisions to be influenced by others is another factor. Barnett
(1971) found three groups of women: (1) the internalizers who set their own
career goals, (2) the identifiers who set goals based on the influence of
significant others, and (3) the compliers who had no career goals and selected
options at the last minute.
Career role models also influence women's career decisions. Several writers
have found that daughters of working mothers have a higher career orientation
than daughters of homemakers. However, this finding is tempered by the mother's
satisfaction with her work role. Within some occupational fields and areas of
study, there have been few female role models. This fact has supported the high
distribution of women in traditionally female occupations.
What Are the Characteristics of Women With High Career Orientation?
A summary of factors associated with high career commitment gives clues about
other factors that affect women's career decisions. These include positive
self-concepts and higher self-esteem; male-associated characteristics such as
self-directedness, assertiveness, and independence as well as female-associated
characteristics; access to role models who set high educational and occupational
aspirations; willingness to modify family roles to accommodate careers; higher
educational levels; and achievement needs that are higher than affiliation
MEN'S ROLE IN PARENTING AND HOMEMAKING IN THEIR FAMILIES
Research on men in family roles has also been neglected until recently. As
women are placing increased emphasis on work roles, men's family roles are being
Do Men Participate in Family Roles?
Miller (1984) describes research indicating that men spend little time
participating in household and child-rearing activities. Time spent on
child-rearing tasks by men average from 1.7 to 2.8 hours per week. Fathers do
spend more time playing with their children, an average of 9 hours per week. Men
spend an average of 11.2 hours per week on household tasks as compared to 53.2
hours for wives who work outside the home. Some research is indicating a shift
toward greater balance in time allocation for dual-earner couples.
Are Men Psychologically Involved with Family?
Fathers report being highly psychologically involved with their families.
They report that they more often think about family than about work and that the
most important things that have happened to them relate to family. Also, when
asked whether family or work provided more satisfaction, less than 5 percent
indicated work, about 50 percent said they receive equal satisfaction from work
and family, and about 45 percent see family as more satisfying than work.
Are Men Competent Parents?
Recent research has focused on men's parenting behaviors using observational
techniques. Fathers have been found to be competent and responsive caretakers,
both in terms of their use of certain caretaking behaviors and responsiveness to
infant cues. Observations with infants show fathers to be active and competent
caretakers. Children show strong attachment to both father and mother as
compared to strangers. They tend to seek fathers for play activities and mothers
when they are fatigued, alarmed, or stressed.
How Does Parenting Benefit Fathers?
Fathers who are more actively involved in parenting report that they have
more open communication with their children, know their children better, and
enjoy being with their children. Some fathers report more conflicts with their
children but feel that this is healthy and results in a more realistic view of
THE NEEDS OF CHILDREN
Several writers speak to the needs of children. Etzioni (1983) suggests that
whereas basic parenting does not require a mother at home, it does require that
one or both parents be involved in active parenthood with enough time, energy,
and commitment for effective parenting.
Research on the effects of parents' working has focused on maternal
employment. Some contend that this represents a bias, in that there is no
evidence suggesting that mothers' or fathers' employment has only good or only
bad effects on all children in all circumstances. Some studies suggest that
maternal employment has a more negative effect on sons than on daughters. Other
research shows benefits of maternal employment. There is a need for future
research to focus on family rather than maternal employment patterns and to
expand the effects on children to include social, emotional, and behavioral as
well as cognitive and achievement effects. In addition to studying what is,
researchers need to imagine what could be. Social changes are occurring to
accommodate the needs of families in the family-career connection. These changes
are being initiated by community members, employers, and public policymakers.
NEW DIRECTIONS FOR CAREER DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS
People need to recognize that planning for career roles and planning for
family roles are closely related tasks. Many have felt the pain of competition
between career and family roles, but few have had assistance in clarifying the
conflicts and developing career and family goals that are personally satisfying
and mutually supportive to other family members. The following goals can provide
a framework to enhance career development programs. Programs can help youth and
--Increase awareness of current and future trends that affect the
family-career connection. These trends are found in various fields such as labor
market statistics, policy information, and family and career development
research. Materials and strategies that integrate these trends are needed.
However, information is not enough. Imaging techniques can be used to
personalize the meaning of these trends for individual life plans.
--Identify and cope with family and career development stages that carry
heavy role demands. When family and career development are discussed
concurrently, individuals can recognize that some stages carry heavier role
demands than others. Many strategies are available to moderate role demands.
Career development programs need to allow participants the freedom to select the
strategies that are most congruent with their goals and values. These strategies
include timing, accommodation, reduction in family size, and negotiation. Timing
strategies include such decisions as when and whether to marry, start a family,
or enter into a career. Accommodation includes redefinition of standards of
performance for career and family, thus freeing energy and time to deal with
both roles. Reduction of size of family decreases family demands and the length
of time spent in high-demand family development stages. Finally, negotiation
involves being open within families to reassigning roles among family members.
--Identify and deal with barriers to implementing their family-career plans.
Barriers to implementing new family-career goals include those within the
individual, within the family, within the employment situation and within the
community and broader society. First, these barriers need to be identified. When
they are within the individual or the family, a variety of counseling
experiences can be helpful in reducing both individual conflicts and in
increasing understanding and cooperation within the family. Barriers within the
employment situation and community can be reduced through such strategies as
carefully evaluating employment situations in light of both career and family
variables and using advocacy measures to increase employer and community
awareness of benefits and services needed to support the family-career
--Increase understanding of the personal benefits of combining family and
career. Those men and women who are combining career and family in
nontraditional ways are reporting benefits to self and family. Helping people
understand these benefits can increase motivation for reevaluation and change.
Career-oriented women seem to combine male-associated characteristics such as
self-directedness, assertiveness, independence, and self-sufficiency with more
traditional feminine characteristics. Men who assume primary responsibility for
child care tend to behave more like fathers in their interactions with their
children but more like mothers in their willingness to assume primary
responsibility. They also report better understanding of and communication with
their children. Such testimony from parents suggesting positive benefits can
help women and men develop belief in new options.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Barnett, R. C. "Personality Correlates of Vocational Planning." GENETIC
PSYCHOLOGY MONOGRAPHS 83 (May 1971):309-356.
Etzioni, A. AN IMMODEST AGENDA: REBUILDING AMERICA BEFORE THE 21ST CENTURY.
New York: New Press, 1983.
Harmon, L. W. "Women's Working Patterns Related to Their SVIB Housewife and
'Own' Occupational Scores." JOURNAL OF COUNSELING PSYCHOLOGY 14 (1967):299-301.
Miller, J. V. FAMILY-CAREER CONNECTION: A NEW FRAMEWORK FOR CAREER
DEVELOPMENT. Information Series no. 288. Columbus: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult,
Career, and Vocational Education, The National Center for Research in Vocational
Education, The Ohio State University, 1984. ED 246 307.